Call for fairer spread of housing across Guernsey

News imageBBC An aerial image of St Sampson's parish in the north of Guernsey on a clear dayBBC
A St Sampson's douzenier said Guernsey's north "should not be the default dumping ground for housing"

St Sampson's douzeniers are calling for housing developments to be distributed more evenly across Guernsey rather than the majority being in the north.

Ahead of a States debate on housing site allocations they said they supported the push for more homes, but have concerns about where they are being built with current proposals placing 57.3% of new housing in the north of the island.

The douzeniers said their concerns were focused on the pressure on infrastructure rather than opposition to new homes being built.

The States Development & Planning Authority said "there has been a policy decision to share more fairly the building of homes across the island".

Next week States members are set to debate the latest Island Development Plan - which includes new housing zones, including two in the north at Route Carré and Sandy Hook.

The douzeniers said the addition of the 50 plus houses across these two sites meant the building of more than 1,400 homes between 2025 and 2030 has been earmarked for sites in the north.

As part of their campaign Fair Share for the North they said this represented 57.3% of the total housing stock planned.

'Can't cope'

St Sampson's Douzenier Anne Jacob said the north "should not be the default dumping ground for housing".

Karl Guille, also a St Sampson douzenier, said his main concern was the cumulative impact of development rather than individual proposals: "The problem actually is one of volume.

"The junctions simply can't cope with the predicted additional traffic flows."

Gary Yarwood, a Forest resident, said more homes were needed to help younger people trying to get onto the housing ladder.

"I've got children aged 25 to 33 and they've got lots of friends and a lot of people left Guernsey because they can't afford to buy homes," he said.

"They've got to go somewhere. I don't think it's unreasonable to build some in St Sampson's."

One resident of St Pierre du Bois said "there's so much scope for property development, but they're hindered because of current policy".

She argued there were still suitable locations available for development and suggested taller buildings should also be considered.

"In Singapore, I used to see developments that were six-storeys tall. Why aren't we doing something like that?" she asked.

News imageA man wearing sunglasses, a white shirt and cream jacket decorated with various pins is stood in front of La Chambre de la Douzaine in St Sampson.
Joe Abbotts, Constable for the Parish of St Sampson, said all areas of the island should share developments evenly

However, some residents in the south of the island also expressed concerns about the pace of development.

A Forest resident said traffic around existing and proposed schemes was already causing frustration.

"The traffic is going to be atrocious", she said. "We're not Hong Kong, but it's going that way."

St Sampson's Constable Joe Abbotts said there was widespread agreement more housing was needed across the island, but argued development should be shared more evenly between parishes.

He said residents in the north were willing to accept further development, but believed other areas should contribute more.

"We don't mind taking our fair share, just not everything," Abbotts added.

Deputy Neil Inder, President of the Development & Planning Authority, said he understood concerns raised by residents in the north.

"I have significant sympathy for the northern parishes who believe that they are or have taken the brunt of housing development over time," he said.

Inder said if the proposed site allocations were approved by the States, detailed traffic and infrastructure assessments would be considered through the planning application process.

"If the planning officers are not convinced traffic matters can be dealt with, that will significantly influence the planning outcome," he said.

Follow BBC Guernsey on X, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to channel.islands@bbc.co.uk.