Isle of Man livestock worrying law to be reviewed
BBCThe Isle of Man's livestock worrying laws are to be reviewed after the results of a public consultation suggested strong support for irresponsible dog owners to face tougher punishments.
Of the nearly 250 people who responded, 87% said the current law was not sufficiently robust, the Manx government said.
Livestock worrying occurs when a dog chases, attacks or distresses livestock. It can either kill or injure animals directly or cause pregnant ewes to lose their lambs.
"We're still relying on a law from 1990 that is not terribly effective when investigating attacks, so you have to catch the dog in the act," complained Sarah Comish, general secretary of the Manx National Farmers' Union.
The Department of Environment and Rural Affairs (DEFA) and the Isle of Man Constabulary will now examine how any changes to the law could be made practical, fair and enforceable.
What does the current law say?
The current maximum fine is £5,000.
The law only applies on agricultural land.
There is no requirement to keep dogs on leads near livestock, and police can only seize a dog under limited circumstances.
What do farmers want?
"The definition of 'under control' means on a lead," said Comish.
"Any other method of assessing whether a dog's under control or not is too vague and there are too many grey areas," she said.
Comish also called for police to have powers to enter properties and seize dogs for DNA testing, and for higher fines for those who break the law.
In England and Wales, fines for owners whose dogs attack livestock are now unlimited.
'Problem owners'
An MNFU survey suggested a majority of farmers on the island had been affected by livestock worrying every year since 2022.
Comish said attacks had risen alongside a rise in dog ownership on the island, and were often down to "problem owners" rather than "problem dogs".
She said the full cost of an attack was hard to measure, as ewes stressed by being chased could later lose their lambs.
"You don't see the consequences of that until lambing time sometimes," she explained.
The government has asked dog owners to keep their pets under proper control around livestock.
Some respondents to the union's survey suggested farmers should improve their fencing but Comish said: "I think a farmer's obligations are to make sure their fencing is good enough to keep stock in, not the people's dogs out."
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
