Health secretary denies cover-up over NHS Grampian issues

News imageGetty Images Angela Constance in a corridor at the Scottish Parliament. She is wearing a black top with large, white polka dots on it and is carrying a blue folder.Getty Images
Angela Constance denied there had been a "cover-up" over issues at NHS Grampian

The health secretary has denied a cover-up surrounding an unreleased report showing that 19 deaths at a health board could have been avoided.

Angela Constance said she was "not satisfied that all questions have been asked or answered" about how concerns over hepatobiliary care at NHS Grampian were handled.

It comes after Dr Mohammed Habib claimed he had contacted the Scottish government on four separate occasions and gone to the police and the lord advocate to raise issues over patient safety.

Constance has ordered an independent review into hepatobiliary surgery at the board, saying she wants "100% transparency" for the sake of patients and staff in order to ensure public confidence.

Habib alleged two people had died after having the wrong procedure performed on them and has called for NHS Grampian to face a corporate homicide probe.

In an unpublished review leaked by the medic, which was carried out in 2022, experts found 19 avoidable deaths among 45 patients in liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI).

News imageDr Mohammed Habib has short, grey hair and glasses. He is sitting indoors and is wearing a dark blazer over a checked shirt. The image is a close-up portrait-style photograph taken from the chest up.
Dr Mohammed Habib has called for the health board to face a corporate homicide inquiry

Humza Yousaf, who was health secretary at the time, and the chief medical officer, Sir Gregor Smith, both saw the report.

Habib wrote to the Scottish government four times, in 2023, 2024, 2025 and earlier this year, to raise his concerns.

His disclosure came a week after Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) found "major deficiencies" in leadership and culture at the health board.

NHS Grampian's chief executive, Laura Skaife-Knight, said the board would be "open and transparent" in co-operating with the review.

'Absolute clarity'

Constance told BBC Scotland's The Sunday Show she wanted "absolute clarity" from the review as to "who knew what, when, and what action was taken, and why".

She said she "did not have a satisfactory answer" over why the 2022 report was not published.

"I've asked that question and I will continue to have follow-up discussions with NHS Grampian on this and other matters," she told the programme.

"As a minister we will be included in the scope of this review - that will be current ministers as well as past ministers, NHS and Scottish government officials will all be within the scope of this fully independent review."

She added: "From the information I have seen that has been reported, it is clear the Scottish government knew of the 2022 report.

"What I now want to be assured of is how closely we were looking at the details of that report and what was the response at the time and that is why we need that independent review, totally independent of the Scottish government."

News imageGetty Images An aerial overview of the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary campus.Getty Images
Dr Habib leaked a report into patient care at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary

Constance said she would not be drawn on "hypotheticals or speculations" around what actions could, or would, be taken if issues of professional misconduct were found.

She said the Scottish government's permanent secretary had issued an instruction to all officials and health board chief executives to preserve records which may be included in the review.

Constance said the scope of the review would be outlined in the Scottish Parliament this week, but added that ministers would not have to wait for its outcome before any relevant reports were made to authorities.

"If there are issues of probity, patient safety, professional misconduct, or any other matters that the reviewer finds, they will be able to report that directly, whether that is to the crown office, general medical council, police or the health board," she said.

"My central concern is patient confidence and as we have heard from a number of patients in NHS Grampian, they need full answers and complete assurance over why decisions were taken."

News imageGetty Images Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie standing up at the Scottish Parliament, wearing a red blazer over a black top.Getty Images
Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie raised issues over the independence of the review

Scottish Labour's health spokeswoman, Jackie Baillie, said she had no faith in the review being fully independent if the Scottish government was setting out its terms.

She said a public inquiry may be required "in the long term" to fully explore the issues.

She also said she supported the chief medical officer being brought before Holyrood to answer questions from MSPs.

Baillie told the Sunday Show: "Right at the heart of this is the collusion and the cover-up between the Scottish government and NHS Grampian.

"Public inquiries take a long time, but the independent review cannot be run by the Scottish government. They cannot provide the secretariat, neither can NHS Grampian, it has to be independent, we're not marking our own homework here."

'Unprecedented' findings

First minister John Swinney called for "dramatic action" to be taken in the wake of the HIS report, published on 12 November.

It accused senior leadership at NHS Grampian of failing to learn from previous mistakes and causing "repeated and unavoidable harm" to patients.

HIS medical director, Dr Simon Watson, described the report as "the most serious review" the healthcare watchdog had ever written, calling its findings "unprecedented".

An external intervention support team has been appointed to oversee improvements at the board.

The 2022 review leaked by Habib looked at 45 patients in the care of hepatobiliary services at ARI between 2015 and 2021.

It said 31 had died, 19 of them from consequences found to be "unavoidable".

The report also said the mortality rate for major liver resections was 12% after 30 days and 18% after 90 days – well above the expected rate of 2.2%.

Yousaf, who became first minister after his stint as health secretary, said he supported the review and would release any relevant minutes from the period.

NHS Grampian said it would take "immediate steps to secure and preserve relevant information, files and records as part of this process."