Letby prosecutors knew expert witness was under investigation

News imageCheshire Police Image is a mugshot of Lucy Letby, taken after her arrest. She has long blonde hair and has a neutral facial expression.Cheshire Police
Prof Peter Hindmarsh was under investigation by the General Medical Council when he gave evidence against Lucy Letby

Police and prosecutors knew an expert witness against Lucy Letby was under investigation over his fitness to practise when he gave evidence at her trial.

Prof Peter Hindmarsh testified that he believed that two babies Letby was accused of attempting to murder had been poisoned with insulin.

Before the first of his two court appearances, however, Hindmarsh had been referred to the General Medical Council (GMC).

The BBC has learned the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) knew this before he went on to appear for a second time.

The CPS said it had "met all its disclosure obligations... and no objections were raised by the defence at any stage in relation to expert evidence".

Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others - one on two occasions - and sentenced to 15 whole-life prison sentences.

The BBC has attempted to contact Hindmarsh, who voluntarily removed himself from the GMC register before the investigation concluded.

'Only explanation'

In November 2022, Prof Hindmarsh gave evidence to Letby's trial at Manchester Crown Court, telling the jury that the blood sugar of a child known as Child F fell worryingly low for a persistent length of time.

Skin injection would not fit with the 17 hours of hypoglycaemia the baby experienced, he said, as that would require repeated injections.

He said infusion would be "probably the most likely way of achieving the blood glucose effect that we have observed".

Giving evidence in February 2023, Hindmarsh told the court that poisoning was the only reasonable explanation for the blood readings of a baby, referred to as Child L, who was on the neonatal unit in early April 2016 at the Countess of Chester Hospital.

The court heard Child L's blood glucose levels remained low throughout 9, 10 and 11 April, even after an intravenous line and the connected bag containing the nutrients were replaced.

Jurors were told subsequent blood examinations found the baby boy's insulin level was at the very top of the scale the equipment was capable of measuring.

Hindmarsh, an expert in paediatric endocrinology at University College London at the time, agreed the readings could only be explained by "somebody having given insulin to [Child L]".

Shortly before this second appearance in court, the CPS had learned of the GMC investigation.

The BBC has not been able to verify the exact cause of his referral to the GMC, but the Guardian has reported it followed a complaint from Great Ormond Street Hospital, which, the newspaper said, had terminated his contract the year before.

According to guidance issued by the CPS in 2022, if information is received that "casts doubt on the competence and/or credibility of an expert witness... the disclosure implications need to be considered".

It adds "the methodology used by the expert may be discredited" and "such information may render past convictions unsafe".

The guidance adds: "In deciding whether action is needed in such cases, the overriding principle to be considered is public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system."

The BBC has asked the CPS whether it had any plans to refer the use of Hindmarsh as an expert witness in the Letby prosecution to its director of legal services.

No response has been received.

The CPS said regulatory investigations were separate and independent of criminal proceedings, and the existence of an investigation did not determine whether evidence was admissible or reliable.

According to the Guardian, Letby's defence team, when initially told of the investigation into Hindmarsh, did not make an application to put the information before the jury because the CPS had said it would oppose it.

The opposition was said to be because the GMC had not reached a final conclusion.

The Guardian reported the CPS had seemingly not been told of a previous tribunal ruling and that Hindmarsh had been barred from treating patients.

The investigation into Hindmarsh never concluded because, according to GMC records, he "relinquished" his registration in November 2024 through a process known as "voluntary erasure".

The GMC has not responded to the BBC's request for comment.

Listen to the best of BBC Radio Merseyside on Sounds,watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Merseyside on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.