Choke collars and doggy daycare - what animal welfare reform means for you

News imageGetty Images A brown and white dog is standing side on. It is wearing a bright yellow collar with a silver bell attached and a second black and yellow collar. The second collar has a larger plastic box attached to it.Getty Images
The proposed welfare reforms include a ban on the use of handheld remote-controlled electronic shock collars

The use of choke chains and electronic shock collars (e-collars) on cats and dogs could be a thing of the past in Northern Ireland.

The proposals are part of a raft of animal welfare reforms announced by the Department of Environment, Agriculture and Rural Affairs (Daera) earlier this week, which Minister Andrew Muir hopes to have in place before the next assembly election in May.

Doggy daycare facilities and those who offer home boarding services for pet owners could also be affected as the reforms could see those types of establishments brought under the animal boarding licensing regime.

Sue McKee, who runs Doggos Doggy Day Care in Dromore, County Down, said she welcomes any "sensible regulations" but hopes the cost of any licence will not have a "knock-on effect to small businesses".

"If you aren't putting the dog's welfare at the forefront of your business, then you've no place in the industry," she added.

News imageSue McKee A woman with short grey hair smiles into the camera. She is wearing a dark top and long silver earrings.Sue McKee
Sue McKee said she would welcome any "sensible" regulations on doggy daycare and home boarding

What has been proposed in the reforms?

Muir plans to ban the use of handheld remote-controlled e-collars, choke collars without a stop mechanism and prong collars on cats and dogs.

Responding to Daera's consultation, 50.4% of respondents agreed to the banning of e-collars, 52.9% said choke collars should be done away with and 54.4% said prong collars should no longer be used.

Daera said while responses were "closely divided", the results have not been considered in isolation but alongside "available scientific and veterinary evidence", legal advice, impact assessments and how the changes will be enforced.

News imageGetty Images A metal dog prong collar on a white background. The chain has a number of exposed metal pieces.Getty Images
Prong collars are described as training aids and apply pressure around an animal's neck when a lead is pulled

It said the main arguments for banning them included the "potential for pain, fear, anxiety, stress, physical injury and adverse behavioural effects".

Alice Palombo, from Cats Protection, "strongly supports" the ban.

She added that the charity is also in favour of a ban on other training collars even though they would not be used on cats.

The reforms also include the mandatory microchipping of dogs by eight weeks old and owners must update the animal's records following a change in ownership or keeper details with a 21 day timeframe.

If the keeper of a dog is also the breeder, that must also be confirmed.

On whether the reforms will be in place by the beginning of May, a Daera spokesperson said while implementation remains "subject to completion of necessary steps, the Department is actively progressing the legislation with the objective of completing it before the end of the mandate".

Does the rest of the UK allow training collars?

The rules around the use of electronic, choke and prong collars differ across the rest of the UK.

Wales have banned e-collars outright and choke and prong collars are "not acceptable" under the Government's codes or practice for the welfare of dogs.

Scotland has not banned any of the collars but their misuse can breach animal welfare laws.

England did attempt to ban the use of e-collars in 2018 but all three collars are still legal, again, as long as they are used within animal welfare laws.

Doggy daycare and home boarding

News imageA woman with dark rimmed round glasses and long red hair looks into the camera. She is wearing red lipstick and a navy fleece. She is standing in front of a building that says USPCA.
The USPCA's Siobhan McHaffie said the "devil is in the detail" when it comes to any reforms

The wider animal welfare reform programme includes home boarding and doggy daycare, with steps being taken to bring those types of establishments within the animal boarding licensing regime.

Muir said the move will give those who use those facilities "confidence" they are "accordingly licensed".

Siobhan McHaffie from the animal charity the USPCA said while there are some "brilliant" doggy day care facilities in Northern Ireland, she has heard some "horror stories" from those who have left their pets off at even licensed facilities.

"For example we had reports from a lady who left her dog in overnight and when their dog came back the next day it was shaking, it was hiding under the table and she discovered it had a shock collar on it," she told BBC Radio Ulster's Evening Extra programme.

"The provider, when [the pet owner] contacted them, said yes, she routinely uses them to stop dogs barking.

"So we do welcome the licensing coming in, absolutely, but the devil's in the detail and the consultation that'll need to happen beforehand."

A spokesperson for Daera said doggy daycare and home boarding is a "separate review of the existing animal boarding legislation" and was not included in the consultation around training collars.

The department said it has contacted more than 150 existing boarding licence holders and the NI Companion Animal Welfare Group as part of the review.

This process began at the beginning of November and ends on 7 December.

What other animal welfare reforms were mentioned by Daera?

Muir said he "hopes" Lucy's Law, which will ban the third-party sale and supply of puppies and sale of kittens, will be passed by Stormont in January and will come into force in April 2027.

Speaking on Evening Extra, he also confirmed that proposals to strengthen regulation of dog breeding establishments will soon be published for consultation.

Daera said "further work" on mandatory cat microchipping and regulation of rescue and rehoming organisations will also consider consultation feedback.