Radical rebels or insular snobs? The bohemian British artists' group still stirring debate

News imageThe Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell Interior with the Artist's Daughter (c1935-36) by Vanessa Bell depicts Angelica reading (Credit: The Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell)The Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell

The Bloomsbury Group, a coterie of early-20th-Century artists and writers – which included author Virginia Woolf – is still divisive. Were they forward-thinking or cliquey? And what was the "devastating deception" at the heart of their circle? A new exhibition in London explores the work of its prominent members Vanessa Bell and Duncan Grant.

In the early 1900s, a small group of free-thinking writers, artists and intellectuals began gathering in Bloomsbury, London. Their members included – among others – the acclaimed writer Virginia Woolf; her sister, the artist Vanessa Bell; and later the economist John Maynard Keynes and the author EM Forster.

The "Bloomsbury Group", as they became known, embraced queerness and polyamory, and saw themselves as experimental architects of a modern and more open-minded Britain that we now take for granted. As the US wit Dorothy Parker reportedly quipped: "They lived in squares, painted in circles and loved in triangles."

The trailblazing group was celebrated for their writing, their style and the forward-thinking abstraction of their bold and colourful art and design, vividly expressed at Charleston, a Sussex farmhouse whose walls, furniture and textiles became the canvas of its primary occupants, Vanessa Bell and the artist Duncan Grant.

News imageYale Centre for British Art/ Paul Mellon Fund/ Estate of Duncan Grant Self-portraits by Vanessa Bell (c1915) and Duncan Grant (c1920) (Credit: Yale Centre for British Art/ Paul Mellon Fund/ Estate of Duncan Grant)Yale Centre for British Art/ Paul Mellon Fund/ Estate of Duncan Grant
Self-portraits by Vanessa Bell (c1915) and Duncan Grant (c1920) (Credit: Yale Centre for British Art/ Paul Mellon Fund/ Estate of Duncan Grant)

The house embodied the principles of their radical design enterprise, The Omega Workshops (co-founded with the painter and art critic Roger Fry), which merged avant-garde art with interior decoration.

The exhibition explores the partnership between Vanessa – who was in an open marriage with the art critic Clive Bell – and Duncan, who was gay

More than 300 examples of their groundbreaking paintings, ceramics, textiles and decorated furniture are on display at Tate Britain's new exhibition, Vanessa Bell & Duncan Grant: Inside Bloomsbury. It explores the creative and at times romantic partnership of more than 50 years between Vanessa – who was in an open marriage with the art critic Clive Bell – and Duncan, who was gay.

Highlights include a reconstruction of their Charleston studio, and their 50-piece hand-painted Famous Women Dinner Service: a project that they worked on so closely together, co-curator Thomas Kennedy tells the BBC, that for each plate, "it's really difficult to see who the artist is."

But there was also a darker side to the group. The perceived insularity of this upper-middle-class clique led to allegations of elitism and snobbery by critics such as Wyndham Lewis, who satirised their salon politics and self-congratulatory taste-making in his 1930 novel The Apes of God. Others have criticised their antisemitism, particularly evident in the diary and correspondence of Virginia Woolf, though her husband Leonard was Jewish.

News imageEstate of Duncan Grant/ Photo by Tate/ Mark Heathcote & Abbie Soanes Bathing by Duncan Grant (c1911) is among the artworks on display at a Tate Britain exhibition (Credit: Estate of Duncan Grant/ Photo by Tate/ Mark Heathcote & Abbie Soanes)Estate of Duncan Grant/ Photo by Tate/ Mark Heathcote & Abbie Soanes
Bathing by Duncan Grant (c1911) is among the artworks on display at a Tate Britain exhibition (Credit: Estate of Duncan Grant/ Photo by Tate/ Mark Heathcote & Abbie Soanes)

For some, these outwardly progressive changemakers were hypocrites. As Alison Light notes in Mrs Woolf and the Servants (2007): "Virginia's dependence on her servants plays havoc with any easy celebration of either her or her sister… as bohemian, free women, creating a new kind of life." 

A familial idyll or devastating deception?

A devastating deception also cast a shadow over the group. Duncan Grant's painting The Hammock, Charleston (c1921-3) places Vanessa Bell at its centre surrounded by her children and their tutor but conceals a secret that the adult members of the Bloomsbury Group kept from the children: the youngest child, Angelica, though brought up as Clive's, is in fact Grant's own.

"He's painted it to look like a familial idyll," Dr Jon King, author of Vanessa Bell and Charleston: Motherhood, Queerness and the Domestic Imagination (2026), tells the BBC. The painting "speaks to Charleston as a retreat but it also speaks to emotionally complex relations", he says. "In the composition, the family are all held in a single space, yet each figure is isolated." To the right, Angelica walks her own path, trundling her toy dog behind her.

News imageNorth East Museums/ Laing Art Gallery The Hammock, Charleston (c1921-3) by Duncan Grant depicts an idyllic domestic scene (Credit: North East Museums/ Laing Art Gallery)North East Museums/ Laing Art Gallery
The Hammock, Charleston (c1921-3) by Duncan Grant depicts an idyllic domestic scene (Credit: North East Museums/ Laing Art Gallery)

Angelica was finally told the truth when she was 18 but was instructed never to mention it again. She broke the silence in her 1984 memoir, Deceived with Kindness, which shattered romantic notions of the Bloomsbury Group as free and open-minded thinkers, describing the "precarious paradise" that she grew up in, and the profound emotional toll of the lie.

The group's decision to raise Angelica as Clive's child was, believes King, largely due to "social propriety" and the desire to "protect Angelica's inheritance from Clive Bell's family". As Angelica writes in her memoir: "It is… the conventionality of the deception that is surprising."

The group's artistic legacy

Yet, for King, the family's unusual domestic arrangement is a distraction and, viewing it through a modern lens, misleading. "Today we have more models of what queer family is," he points out, whereas this family was created at a time when homosexual activity was still illegal.

Their role in introducing post-impressionism to this country changed the face of British art – Thomas Kennedy

"I think the sensationalism around the Bloomsbury Group's private lives all too often overshadows a true assessment of their artistic legacy," agrees Kennedy. "One thing we want to do in this exhibition is celebrate Vanessa and Duncan as painters whose role in introducing post-impressionism to this country, and breaking down the barriers between fine and decorative art, changed the face of British art."

News imageThe Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell Interior with the Artist's Daughter (c1935-36) by Vanessa Bell depicts Angelica reading (Credit: The Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell)The Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell
Interior with the Artist's Daughter (c1935-36) by Vanessa Bell depicts Angelica reading (Credit: The Charleston Trust/ Estate of Vanessa Bell)

Vanessa's belief that art should permeate everyday life is evident in her painting Interior with the Artist's Daughter (c1935-6). Here, a teenage Angelica, absorbed in her reading, merges into the graphic textiles and striped rows of books of the studio: a place she described as "the sanctuary in which I spent the most treasured hours of my life". According to King, "Vanessa assembled a world at Charleston that was far removed from the troubles of the outside world, which may not have been perfect, but… her children were given immense creative freedom and an education there."

Vanessa and Duncan's unconventional relationship

The fabric of their home also reflects the tenderness of Angelica's biological parents' relationship. In Vanessa's former bedroom, you can still see the family's lurcher that Duncan painted on the wall to guard her while she slept. Letters between "Nessa" and "My Darling Bear", held in Tate's collection, also convey their deep affection.

Their working relationship was also intimate. Vanessa's Still Life on Corner of a Mantelpiece and Duncan's The Mantelpiece (both 1914) were painted side by side. Tate conservators discovered that they even used the same tubes of paint, explains Kennedy, but "Vanessa uses bright bold blocks of colour and Duncan… incorporated collage elements." 

There was a loving gaze, too, in the numerous portraits they painted of each other. The last of these was Duncan's 1961 pencil and biro drawing of Vanessa shortly after her death. This recently discovered portrait, currently undergoing conservation at Charleston, is described in the show's catalogue as "the final articulation of a partnership in which portraiture was inseparable from love and the domestic world that held them together".

News imageEstates of Duncan Grant and Vanessa Bell/ Tate/ Reece Straw Still-life paintings (1914) by Duncan Grant (left) and Vanessa Bell (right) show similarities in their styles (Credit: Estates of Duncan Grant and Vanessa Bell/ Tate/ Reece Straw)Estates of Duncan Grant and Vanessa Bell/ Tate/ Reece Straw
Still-life paintings (1914) by Duncan Grant (left) and Vanessa Bell (right) show similarities in their styles (Credit: Estates of Duncan Grant and Vanessa Bell/ Tate/ Reece Straw)

But Vanessa and Duncan's relationship also fell short of Bloomsbury ideals. Vanessa, who had her own love affairs, was nevertheless jealous of some of Duncan's friends and lovers. While paintings by Duncan such as Bathing (1911), where athletic male nudes power through wavy water, hint at unrealised queer desires. In 2020, more than 400 of his homoerotic drawings, marked "very private", resurfaced after years hidden beneath a bed. Several appear in the exhibition.

However, for Angelica, the Bloomsbury Group's intellectualism left little space for emotion. The author D H Lawrence, who first met group members in 1914, disparaged their "little swarming selves". "To hear these young people talking really fills me with black fury," he wrote in 1915. "There is never for one second any outgoing of feeling."

They were people who, I think, embraced the observable world in a very direct way – Virginia Nicholson

This may explain why, when Angelica formed an attachment to the writer David "Bunny" Garnett, the group failed to inform her that her future husband had previously not only pursued her mother but was also her father's former lover. Shortly after Angelica was born, Bunny – who was at the time fixated with her parents – had declared a desire to marry Angelica, writing in a letter: "When she is 20, I shall be 46 – will it be scandalous?" Angelica later blamed the doomed marriage on the deception regarding her paternity: "My dream of the perfect father – unrealised – possessed me…" she wrote in her memoir. "My marriage was but a continuation of it."

News imageCharleston Trust A 1961 sketch of Vanessa Bell by Duncan Grant – the two artists were lifelong companions (Credit: Charleston Trust)Charleston Trust
A 1961 sketch of Vanessa Bell by Duncan Grant – the two artists were lifelong companions (Credit: Charleston Trust)

According to King, "Bloomsbury bashing", as the cultural critic Christopher Reed called it, has been fanned by homophobia and misogyny. He sees Vanessa and Duncan's legacy as something far more positive: "to not have creative fear and to embrace colour into your life". He concedes that "they weren't always successful because they were seen as a coterie, a privileged bunch who were self-contained", but insists: "that wasn't their vision at all". From stencil-printed walls to some of Britain's first fully abstract paintings, "they wanted people to know that they could do it too".

More like this:

In an interview in the exhibition catalogue, Vanessa's granddaughter, Virginia Nicholson, draws on memory rather than mythology in her appraisal of Vanessa and Duncan. "My own perception is that, as artists, they were not pretentious… neurotic, or ideological, or pompous," she asserts. "They were people who, I think, embraced the observable world in a very direct way and created art that gave joy."

Vanessa Bell & Duncan Grant: Inside Bloomsbury is at Tate Britain, London until 11 April 2027. Charleston in Firle, Sussex is open every Wednesday to Sunday.

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.