Main content

2. Tragic but Brave

Meet Alan and Barbara. A young disabled couple on a mission to change things, whatever the consequences.

Britain in the 1980s is not a good place to be disabled. Discrimination is legal, and rampant. Disabled people are seen as a pitiful burden on society.

So when ITV launches its 27 hour long ‘Telethon’ fundraising extravaganza for the disabled, Barbara Lisicki and her partner Alan Holdsworth, see an opportunity to take a stand.

Presenter: Sophie Morgan
Assistant Producer: Niall Strawson
Original music and sound mix: Julian Corrie
Series Producer: Sarah Shebbeare

A BBC Studios production for BBC Radio 4

Transcript available on the programme website

Available now

15 minutes

Episode 2 Transcript

SOPHIE: It happened on the day I got my A-level results.

A car crash that changed my life forever.

T6 paraplegic is the technical term.

 Today, I've spent more of my life in a wheelchair than not.

Perhaps you're listening with a hint of pity.

And I get it. I would've felt pity for me too back when my legs worked, but I don't.

In fact, there's no self-pity at all.

And there's a reason for that.

It all stems from a gang of mavericks who came together to fight for people like me decades before my crash even happened.

And their story, well, is pretty epic.

SOPHIE: we were gonna break the law. And that was clear.

MIK: It is absolute anarchy.

ARCHIVE: What have you done to the bus? Uh, I've just chained myself to it

DAVID: You felt that you knew that there was going to be change. there had to be change.

Carlo Salvatore: We want jobs, we want human rights, civil rights, We want what you've got.

ARCHIVE: 6.5 million people in this country have no civil rights, and that is a complete outrage.

GILL: It was so, so empowering.

I'm Sophie Morgan, and for BBC Radio 4 and the History Podcast, this is For Pity's Sake'

SOPHIE: Episode two: Tragic but Brave.

BARBARA: I was always a rebellious child, and I got expelled from secondary school. I went to a Catholic convent and their rules and how I was just didn't mesh.

SOPHIE: Meet Barbara Lisicki

BARBARA: I found it absurd that, we had all these rules imposed on us that made no sense

SOPHIE: By all accounts, Barbara's rebellious spirit is a crucial part of this story.

BARBARA: and Ironically, within a month or so of getting expelled, I became ill with the impairment that, I've got now. And, there was a place that everybody that had this diagnosis which is juvenile, rheumatoid arthritis will know from that era, which was in Taplo, in Berkshire. And again, I didn't play by the rules and I almost got kicked out. I mean, imagine getting kicked outta hospital.

They made me use this horrible wheelchair and I didn't like it. I said, I don't want to use a wheelchair. I'm perfectly capable of getting around. And they were insistent. So I corrupted some other, young people And we used to go down to the entrance, chuck our wheelchairs in the bushes and hitchhike down to the pub.

I was only 15, And they used to send people out looking for us, but it never occurred to them that we'd be in a pub. So they never found us.

SOPHIE: Something tells me me and Barbara would have been good mates. Like her, I too got kicked out of school in my early teens, and I also used to escape to the pub when I was in hospital.

SOPHIE: But despite all her absconding, Barbara was smart. She left school with good grades and went on to get a teaching degree.

BARBARA: So I got qualified, as an adult education teacher, and, all the people that I trained with all went off and got jobs straight away. And when I started turning up to interviews and then not getting the jobs, it suddenly struck me that something was going on. The whole approach was that I was a problem and I had to address the problem that I was presenting.

I think it's hard for people to, to reckon with now, but in the seventies and eighties, there was just no way that disabled people had any rights at all.

there was no access, Trying to get out and do things, It was just impossible for people. And there was a lot of exclusion from portrayal of any group of people that wasn't seen as mainstream. disabled people just didn't exist as far as the media was concerned, . But when there was portrayal, it was all tragic but brave. It was pity.

ARCHIVE: I'm gonna make you an offer. I don't think you can refuse. I'm gonna offer you the chance to make a child happy, a real child, really happy. And I guarantee that if you send money to the BBC Children In Need appeal, every penny you give will actually change a child's life for the better

BARBARA: It was sad, pathetic people, um, that were less than everybody else. and so I think from the beginning, I was, angry

SOPHIE: Barbara didn't know it yet, but she wasn't alone in feeling angry.

ALAN: The way that disabled people were portrayed, in the media, was like, you know, beggars holding their hand out, being very grateful for anything they could get and, uh, uh, looking pathetic.

SOPHIE: Meet Alan Holdsworth.

ALAN: AKA Johnny Crescendo. I'm a singer songwriter,

And, um, co-founder of the Tragic but Brave Show.

I had polio when I was 10 months old And, um, I, I used to wear a leg brace basically. Um, you want to belong to everybody who's not disabled. Uh, and that certainly was me in the seventies.

 Our place was in a nursing home or in an institution, or, in a special school. And that's where we belonged why would anyone want to be a member of that club?

BARBARA: I had been told before, uh, many times, that my style of operating, I suppose was quite funny. And so I gave it a go to doing standup comedy. And my first ever gig was, an event called The Workhouse, which was a disability arts event. And it went down a storm.

Every standup will tell you that when you hear people laugh, you think I'm doing something right. And the laughs kept coming

One of my very early gigs was in Milton Keynes and, one of the other people on the bill was singer songwriter Johnny Crescendo

ALAN: I was actually topping the bill but there was also this comic on there called, uh, Wanda, Barbara.

I thought she was quite innovative. I'd never seen a, a disabled standup comic before. And There wasn't that many people like myself, you know, singer, a songwriters writing about disability.

BARBARA: So afterwards. Um, we were in a hotel together. And, uh, I had, um, I had a wine box basically, and, uh,and, uh, we got on

SOPHIE: Needless to say, Alan and Barbara hit it off.

ALAN: And so at some point we thought, rather than just go out individually and like do 45 minutes maybe we could just, put a show together,

BARBARA: and we formed, the Tragic But Brave Show and took it on the road. So there was me, the person that became my partner, Johnny Crescendo, and then, a very, very good performer called Ian Stanton, and we were taking a very political message about disability out to people, and they hadn't heard it before. I think that was the powerful thing about it,

SOPHIE: Let me help you picture these two. Barbara wears thick black eyeliner, bright red lipstick, fishnet gloves on her hands, and has the perfect bob of platinum blonde hair. Think Madonna in the '80s. Alan's more of a hippie: patchwork cap, political T-shirts, and a guitar slung across his chest at all times. You know the sort.

They're good-looking, they're loud, and they're on a mission to change things.

BARBARA: with Johnny's, the song that he was very well known for, his choices and rights, and I want choices and rights in my life. we don't need your charity or you to be paid to care for me, I want choices and rights in my life. and that was the sort of, dig at, the institutions because one of the ways in which disabled people were treated was to be put into institutional settings and sticking us in segregated facilities and we rejected it.

ALAN: Another one, my songs Easy Money. You stick your hand in your pocket. it's easier that way. your conscience rolls on, but your ignorance stays.

it should be about disability rights, not about, charity, and handouts and begging cripples. People wept and gave money and then felt better,

BARBARA: It was challenging. I mean, we didn't want people to feel comfortable. It wasn't like any other type of material that I think people had seen before.

SOPHIE: Between touring the tragic but brave show, Barbara also began to appear on television.

ARCHIVE: Barbara Lisicki Just explain why programs like children in need make you angry, because in fact, they're very popular with large numbers of other viewers. I, I, I agree they're popular and I think one of the reasons for their popularity, because it allows non-disabled people to sit back and feel that they have done something, it isn't just about individuals giving money. It isn't just about mass appeals on television. It is about having some rights, and I want people to realize that disabled people have no rights. If you make a disabled person an object of charity, you are not going to see them as you are equal.

BARBARA: In the UK in the 1980s, we started to get, events like Children In Need and, um, the telethon and what that meant was that disabled people basically became the topic of, events that raised money.

ARCHIVE: Hello. We'd like to tell you about Telethon 85. It's the first 24 hour television show in this country, and it's for charity. Yes, but we haven't told everyone who's in it yet. There's singer Jack Jones, Freddie Star de Connor Cha, and Dave Michael Aspel. Michael Aspel, and I'll have an early night, uh, Andrew, you can't, you and I are in it for the whole 24 hours

BARBARA: One of the big ones, that had a very high profile and was pushed really hard, was the ITV telethon.

ARCHIVE I mean, the, the turnout every year is brilliant. and people are genuinely very generous,

SOPHIE: Here's a bunch of celebrities raving about the 1988 ITV Telethon.

ARCHIVE: isn't handicap kits and things like that. They're underprivileged people. And because we make such a good living in this business, we like to give some of it back. But I have never seen such a gazing I mean, it's just wonderful. I see people on the television and perhaps on the stage at a theater, and they're all here today

SOPHIE: But Barbara and her mates, well, they hate watched it.

BARBARA: we used to go to each other's houses and, watch the telethon I mean, we hated doing it, but we watched it to get the sense of just how bad it was. It, went on hours and hours and hours and people did daft stunts to raise money. , So, you know, shave their heads and, , sitting in a bath of baked beans.

ARCHIVE: Steve, how did you raise the money for telethon? a knitter on and up. We did a fashion show That's fabulous. We've got Joanne and uh, Donna Herena.

You did a dance, didn't you? Yeah. And how much did you raise? 40 pounds. That's great. Mark, how did you do it? We did 28 hours of snooker and darts,

ALAN: towing a double decker bus. jumping into ice pools, uh, I could go on, , it was just Crap TV.

It's uncomfortable to listen back to now. I remember those fundraisers and I remember watching them on telly. I didn't question them. Neither did my parents or my teachers. We all thought we were doing the right thing...

And in 1990, plans were afoot for the biggest telethon yet.

ARCHIVE: Two years ago, ITV held its first telethon, a 27 hour long spectacular, which was watched by 35 million people, had raised a staggering 23 million pounds for charities all over the country. We're holding another telethon this year over the Spring Bank holiday weekend in May, and once again, we'll be trying to raise as much as we can.

ALAN: The way it started was me and Barbara were now living together in Hackney in London, in an apartment and a phone call came through from a youth worker, And said, don't you think we should do a demonstration against the Telethon? And I asked Barbara and Barbara went, yep,

BARBARA: yeah, all right, we'll help.

ALAN: And that moment, that, "Yeah, all right, we'll help," moment, it doesn't feel like much at the time, a passing comment, insignificant, but it's anything but insignificant. In that moment, in their flat in Hackney, Barbara and Alan set in motion a change that will have ripples for decades to come. So that's how it began.

I didn't realize just the amount of people who were really, really angry about the Telethon.

Once I started making phone calls and Barbara made phone calls, it was pretty clear we were gonna have a huge turnout

Taking on the Telethon would be a crucial first step, in what would become a much bigger battle for disability rights.

BARBARA: And that's really when we began to pull together for change. We were taking our own fate into our own hands.

Broadcast

  • Yesterday13:45

Podcast