3. Modern Day Freak Show
Michael Aspel hosts a ‘Fiesta of Fun and Frolics’ at the 1990 ITV Telethon. But there’s trouble ahead...
It's May 1990, and Barbara Lisicki and Alan Holdsworth have gathered their disabled friends and allies to make their mark on this year's ITV Telethon, a twenty-seven-hour fundraising extravaganza for the disabled.
Meanwhile Telethon producer Martin Lucas is working hard to make fundraising films that will resonate with viewers.
Presenter: Sophie Morgan
Assistant Producer: Niall Strawson
Original music and sound mix: Julian Corrie
Series Producer: Sarah Shebbeare
A BBC Studios production for BBC Radio 4
Transcript available on the programme website.
Last on
Episode 3 Transcript
ALAN: The night before the Telethon we were in an arts centre down in London making, signs and placards, and we were thinking of all kind of things. You know, we, we didn't want them all to say the same thing.
I wrote one called Piss on Pity.
SOPHIE: This is the story of how a gang of mavericks from different walks of life came together to fight for disability rights in the UK.
And if you think this story isn't for you, think again, because disability can happen to any of us at any time. Trust me.
I'm Sophie Morgan, and for BBC Radio 4 and the History Podcast , this is ' For Pity's Sake'.
Episode Three, Modern Day Freak Show.
ARCHIVE: Coming soon. The second ITV telephone, once again, I'll be hosting a cornucopia of Conviviality, a Fiesta of Fun and Frolics from ITV studios all over the land. And what we'd like you to do is a watch
BARBARA: We were contacted with a week or two's notice of the telethon being on air and there were loads of trailers for it. I mean, it was really sort of high profile in terms of, getting pushed by ITV
SOPHIE: It's May 1990, and Barbara Lisicki and Alan Holdsworth have gathered their disabled friends to make their mark on this year's ITV Telethon, a twenty-seven-hour fundraising extravaganza for the disabled.
BARBARA: We were very opposed to these public appeals and the way in which it was presented on television because the core idea of raising money was problematic, this idea that disabled people, were the people that had the problem, not that socially, we were discriminated against and segregated.
It was about pity. you know, trying to make people emotional about disabled individuals to say, oh, we must help this person because their life is so horrid. and so pathetic.
ARCHIVE: And now we've got the Newport Conservative Club. Hello ladies. How did you raise the money? Darts matches, and lots of raffles and lovely members. Well, thank you for coming along. You brought the sun out, which is always good news. We've got some clowns over here. Hello. How did you raise your money?
ITV Telethon 1988 had raised twenty-three million pounds.
ARCHIVE: They used to have , people coming onto the telethon with these gigantic cheques, We've got Joanne and uh, Donna Herena. You did a dance, didn't you? Yeah. That's great. Well done. We're gonna be here all day. Come down and see us and give us some money Back to Southampton
BARBARA: And one of the things that, that was part of the telethon is they used to find an individual, disabled, young person, and they'd make a film about them. And the film would be, you know, here's, Mary and Mary can't walk and Mary can't speak and her life is really terrible, but you can help her by donating money so that she can get this bit of equipment that will make her life a bit better. And disabled people were, were sickened by it. It was, it was nasty.
How do you expect any employer to want to employ a disabled person when they see crap like this?
But not ALL disabled people agreed. Some saw the benefits.
MARTIN: the kinds of, films we were asked to make were pretty much in the broad telethon tradition. Little segments of two or three minutes, which were designed, to evoke empathy and sympathy, among viewers uh, and basically to make people want to help by donating money.
SOPHIE: Here's Television producer Martin Lucas.
MARTIN: I was, uh, a producer for Thames Television for many years, specifically in 1990, I was invited to join the team making the telethons as an executive producer, of the various appeal films, which is the standard technique of raising funds in telethons.
I did suspect, that part of the reason I was invited to do it apart from being an excellent producer and director, was that I had this quite reasonable disability myself. A spastic walk inherited from a childhood infection, brain infection.
SOPHIE: In 1990, the pressure's on to raise a record amount of cash.
MARTIN: Basically the idea was to make the people real to the viewer. to make a compelling, sometimes downright emotional, link to people we'd make, a film often about children. it would be cut to very nice, hopefully compelling music. Um, hopefully it would be sympathetic and empathetic rather than exploitative in any way.
SOPHIE: It's the 27th May. Michael Aspel opens the 1990 Telethon to much fanfare. Meanwhile, outside...
some of the supposed recipients of this charitable event, a group of 300 disabled people, are chanting calls to bring the show down.
BARBARA: we basically just went and, had a demonstration outside the ITV studios and blocked the road.
ALAN: I was there at 10 in the morning. We had a PA system by then, and we had, we put that in the center and behind the, the stage where the mics were, were all these placards
BARBARA: and, um, Alan came up with this placard with Piss on, pity on it. And, um, the police confiscated it and said, that's offensive and you can't have it, and took it off.
SOPHIE: And in that moment, they have a slogan and the beginnings of a movement.
BARBARA : The first demonstration was pulled together in a hurry, but we still managed to get, two or 300 people there.
ALAN: That first telephone really did start it all off. Unfortunately, we didn't take names, but, uh, we, we didn't make that mistake second time round.
SOPHIE: because as Cilla Black closes the show on the 1990 ITV telethon, protesters outside decide there will be a second time around.
Only next time, there'll be more prep.
A lot more prep.
SUE: We decided that this could not go on any longer. We had to shut Telethon down. It was doing too much damage to disabled people.
SOPHIE: Meet Sue Elsegood. She was there at that first protest with Barbara and Alan.
SUE: I felt like telethon was a modern day freak show
It made me feel sick, to be honest. 'Cause I think members of the public and the celebrities couldn't understand why were we biting the hand that fed us they just couldn't get their heads around it. But then we were making it clear that what we were fighting for was rights, not charity.
I don't think people really appreciate how disabling society was at that time.
I'm a wheelchair user. I'm not able to walk, stand or mobilize independently, so I'm reliant on 24 7 personal assistance for everyday needs.
In those days, it was very much a question of either being segregated and excluded or having surgery to try and make a person as normal as possible. And this was the world I was in. I couldn't really get out of my flat let alone get to work because there was no public transport it felt like being a prisoner in your own home. I was a young person. I was full of life I still am full of life, but I was just determined to not be excluded from society and all the experiences got all the opportunities that everyone else has.
and so, , when I watched the telethon, it just didn't seem conducive to disabled people taking their place as equal citizens.
SOPHIE: ITV heard the calls for change in 1990, and their plan going forward was to change things.
MARTIN: We all received, educational sessions to, introduce us to the idea which was beginning to spread that disability had to be understood not just as some, local problem for people who were disabled, but was a reflection of the way that society was organized
SOPHIE: Executive producer Martin Lucas again.
MARTIN: You could argue there's no way to compromise what a telethon is, but we thought we were moving towards making more authentic, appeals based on this new, more comprehensive understanding of what disability was.
SOPHIE: Enter Mik Scarlett.
MIK: back in 1990, I was Mick Scarlet up and coming TV presenter who had just started, being the presenter on a, new kids TV show called Beat That. I was disabled, I was a wheelchair user, I was all dressed up in punk gear with bleached hair and I was a minor person, if you know what I mean in the world of television.
everyone knows that kids TV presenters are not viewed as real presenters.
SOPHIE: But then,
MIK: I basically got discovered by Martin Lucas,
when the telethon 92 was in its pre-planning stages, I was asked to come along to some of their pre-planning meetings. They knew that something needed to change. They'd, had that impact from the campaigning, of disabled people to say, no, we need to do something different. But they didn't really know what,
Michael Aspel was standing up giving a speech and Michael Aspel has a disabled son and he said, come on, let's face this all disabled people would like to be cured if they could be, or something like that. And I just saw the shouted from the back bollocks. Unfortunately my voice does carry, so he heard it on stage and an argument ensued. Where I was trying to explain that, I didn't wanna be cured and I, you know, many of the disabled people that I did know didn't.
so afterwards a lot of the production team kind of came up and went, how can we get you involved? Um, and that sort of then led to being asked to present it.
SOPHIE: An offer too good to refuse.
MIK: all of these big charity telethon things have massive names on them. you know, stars do like coming out and doing their bit for charity. You're not getting paid. but this was a prime time show that lots of people watched. So, you know, everyone's got their eye on their career,This was another run on the ladder. , But also I thought that maybe, I could help make it something better than it was. There was an element that when you hired me, you were challenging the stereotype of what a disabled person could be. And because they were listening to me and listening to people like Martin, um, I think we got a little bit more input than possibly we would've done the two years before.
SOPHIE: Telethon 1992 would be different.
MARTIN: We really put effort in to try and, educate the audience that you know, it's not about giving money because they're poor little things. It's about helping people to achieve their potential. So, to an extent, I would say that the radical movement and good luck to them were actually confronting, an enemy that wasn't really there.
SOPHIE: Next time on 'For Pity's Sake'...
ALAN: we knew that we needed to be, very well organized for the 1992, block telethon protest. it was like a military operation. Disabled people came from all over the country they stormed the barricades. Disabled people actually said, no, we're gonna get in this, we're gonna get in.
BARBARA: the aim was to take the event down. The aim was that we wanted to stop it.
MIK: it was. really scary because they didn't hold back.
ARCHIVE: Rights not charity, rights not charity
Broadcast
- Today13:45BBC Radio 4
Podcast
![]()
The History Podcast
For Pity's Sake. The extraordinary story of a group of maverick campaigners.

