Main content

1. The Crippleage

A boy is sent away to a special school for disabled children, only to discover upon leaving at 16, that he has a lot more to offer the world than he's been told.

A young boy is sent away to a special school for disabled children, only to discover upon leaving at sixteen, that he has a lot more to offer the world than he's been brought up to believe.

What he does next, will change the course of disability rights in the UK.

Contributor: David Ruebain, Law Professor and Pro-Vice Chancellor for Culture, Equality and Inclusion at the University of Sussex.

Presenter: Sophie Morgan
Assistant Producer: Niall Strawson
Original music and sound mix: Julian Corrie
Series Producer: Sarah Shebbeare

A BBC Studios production for BBC Radio 4

Transcript available on the programme website.

Available now

14 minutes

Last on

Monday13:45

Episode 1 Transcript

SOPHIE: It happened on the day I got my A level results: a car crash.

A split second, and after that, everything was different.

A textbook crash, I'm told. A young driver, only just passed her test, makes a wrong, distracted decision,

the consequences of which she will have to live with for the rest of her life.

Until that moment, I was like most people. I never thought about my body or what it could or couldn't do.

What I looked like in a little black dress? sure.

But how I moved effortlessly from one place to the next, I took that bit for granted.

Disability, not my problem. I didn't think something like that would ever happen to me.

SOPHIE: I was just eighteen years old when I was told I would never walk again, and that for the rest of my life I would depend on a wheelchair.

 Now picture this.

It's November of two thousand and three. After months of rehabilitation in a spinal unit, I'm on my way to take up the place at art college that I'd accepted just before I had become disabled.

But on arrival, I'm told I can't attend.

The reason? The college isn't wheelchair accessible.

Now I wish I could tell you I was brilliant and defiant in that moment. But I wasn't.

I was eighteen years old, newly paralyzed, and I went home, and I cried. In fact, truth be told, I sobbed.

But somewhere in the mess of that moment, someone said something that changed the course of my life. They said, "They can't do that. There's a law."

 The moment the doctor told me I'd never walk again, and I rolled out of hospital as a manual wheelchair user, I expected my life to crumble, to be ruined forever

but the thing is, it didn't. It wasn't.

I have a great life. I have a life anyone, disabled or not, would deem worth living.

And there's a reason for that.

It's all thanks to a gang of mavericks who came together to fight for people like me decades before my crash happened.

They didn't ask politely. They weren't inspirational in the way people like to make disabled people inspirational. They were mouthy, they were smart, fearless, and at times, they were anarchic.

And they made history.

SOPHIE: This is their story told by them

BARBARA: we were taking our own fate into our own hands.

ARCHIVE: What have you done to the bus? Uh, I've just chained myself to it

ALAN: they stormed the barricades.

ARCHIVE: what do we want? Do we want,

SUE: it was quite empowering to be disobedient

ARCHIVE: you are having to deest me because your vehicles are inaccessible,

MIK: They didn't hold back. it was truly terrifying.

ARCHIVE: Pressure is mounting for the Minister for Disabled people, Nicholas Scott to resign after he admitted misleading the Commons

ARCHIVE: We're extremely angry. We are not weak, and we will never be seen as weak again.

ARCHIVE: A group of disabled people left their wheelchairs and tried to crawl into the House of Commons today.

ARCHIVE: Our problems are not our bodies, they're society. That's our problem.

ARCHIVE: Disability discrimination bill Second reading

Things are gonna change. And we are gonna change them.

I'm Sophie Morgan, and for BBC Radio 4 and the History Podcast this is For Pity's Sake'

Episode One, The Crippleage

DAVID: My name is David Rubin. And, um. I'm chatting to you today, in a personal capacity.

SOPHIE: Meet David. You're gonna get to know him pretty well across this series.

Now, I should explain that most disabled people don't like being called inspirational. It's a term that gets widely misused by non-disabled people when they're talking about us. But I think you'll come to agree that David is, by anyone's metrics, as inspirational as they come.

DAVID: So I was born in 1962, I was born disabled, I was noticeably disabled. I am noticeably disabled. and at that time for young disabled people the default position was very much that, we should be separated and segregated, often in, rural or even remote locations. Both for our own and I think it was felt for everybody else's benefit.

DAVID: We were effectively segregated because we didn't belong with, non-disabled people. and a lot of imagery and representation of us at the time were characterized by, pictures of, and tones of voice involving deep, tragedy and suffering.

And so I certainly felt, and many of us felt that the reason why we were in these special schools was as much because we were upsetting for, other people as it was purportedly for our own benefit. and so my schooling as a child and a teenager was predominantly in schools for disabled children, and in my case, in a boarding school, a special residential school.

SOPHIE: This was common practice in the 1970s.

ARCHIVE: I was in high school when I was first handicapped, but when I needed a wheelchair at 15. I had to leave high school and go to a special school for handicapped girls

DAVID: I think only a matter of a few years before I arrived, its title was that it was a cripeleage. Um, and I think I think probably, illuminates the, perspective that I remember, which is that, our lives were seen principally as tragedies

ARCHIVE: this decision has proved to be the right one. In that there's no feeling of isolation on the part of residence. They're part of a community of all ages and types.

Segregated special schools were seen as the best - and often, only, option for disabled children

DAVID: a good outcome was kindness to us but there shouldn't have been any expectation that, we could do, the range of things that non-disabled children might want to do or aim to do.

ARCHIVE: I would say that at that time a lot of special schooling, maybe most special schooling, was little more than warehousing really, because the expectations of, disabled people were limited and to some extent almost non-existent.

DAVID: The best that could be done for individuals like me was to provide us with a environment where we could be with other people like ourselves, and have some kind of a limited life.

SOPHIE: It wasn't just special schools. Adults too were packed away into institutions.

ARCHIVE: So how do you spend your time just looking, just wasting it? Nothing to do.

 Well, how do your face each day? As it dawns, Just wait for time to go to bed. Go to bed, and go to sleep. Forget it all. Is that the best part of the day? Yeah,

DAVID: although I got on with my peers and I made friends in the special schools that I was at, there wasn't from my perspective, any meaningful education, or any, ambition for me or for us to, have wide horizons or to have, ambitions to go on to do or become, things save in very limited ways.

So there were pathways for people to study tailoring, shoemaking, um, electrical work or secretarial work, all of which were fine, but the expectation being that these were a few of the limited possibilities for us.

Certainly for many of us, me included there wasn't any sense of, um, expectation of a life fully lived.

SOPHIE: There wasn't any expectation of a life fully lived.

David's words are chilling to me.

 As recently as the '70s, my parents' generation, we sent disabled people just like me away, out of sight, out of mind.

DAVID: I remember we used to go as teenagers into the local town, and it was at the time when, you used to be able to find these kind of plastic, models of children, outside of shops, and these children would invariably look like they were disabled so they were wheelchair users or they were walking with a stick, . And the idea is you'd put your loose change in these containers,And people who would go shopping and had some loose change, would then put it in the containers.

 and we used to go into town and see these things. I, I think on one or two occasions, I remember us even going into the shops and asking for the money there and then, uh, in some kind of attempt to sort of, resistance to the imagery that was, being portrayed about us.

But the very fact that one was represented by these little tragic models outside of a shop, which people were meant to donate to, was kind of, expressive of exactly how we were thought. Um, and there were many examples of that. there were various schemes where non-disabled kids would be invited to come and play with us, but often that was just so that they could get their Duke of Edinburgh award badge And once they'd got their badge, We'd no longer see them again.

SOPHIE: But all that changed when at 16, David was allowed to leave special school.

DAVID: It transpired that I'd only achieved two O levels, and only at Grade C, which, I think was indicative of the fact that I didn't really learn anything at all.

SOPHIE: And yet, despite his few qualifications-

DAVID: I didn't want to stop studying. I actually enjoyed learning things, and so I contacted the local secondary schools comprehensives, and in fact, mostly I didn't get anywhere with them But one particular school, Hampstead comprehensive, was exceptionally welcoming to me and I would say they turned my life around really,

if I hadn't gone to that school, my life would be very different now actually, I have no idea what my life would be like now. Um, but it would've been completely different from what it is.

I built a group of friends and what amazed me about them was that they, all of them, regardless of their so-called academic ability or otherwise, had huge ambitions for what they wanted to do with their lives. And I found that quite amazing really. I also began to do well academically there and, did my O level retakes and then A levels

and they pushed me to apply for university, which I did, and eventually found myself somewhat, um, dazed, but, um, at, um, at Oxford University

I got a place to study politics, philosophy, and economics.

And it was there amongst the dreaming spires of Oxford that David began to make sense of his childhood.

DAVID: Whereas I had thought that all of the difficulties in my life was because I happened to be disabled. I became very, um, vexed and even angry and, perturbed about systems and structures, which would. put people in boxes in the way that I had been put in a box, and during university became involved in the the growing campaign to enact legislation to give civil rights to disabled people rather than to rely on charity and beneficence for our wellbeing.

Um, and I found new home in that place.

 In fact, I had another period of my life where I made lots of new friends of disabled people, except this time it was very different than in the special school

 we came together with at least some sense of identities of righteous indignation rather than as victims.

SOPHIE: We're going to come back to David across the series because he will go on to have a starring role in this story about the fight for disability rights. And what you've just heard is just the very first chapter of a life very much fully lived.


Broadcast

  • Monday13:45

Featured in...

Podcast