Report: England edge towards World Cup exit despite PNG winpublished at 11:24 GMT
11:24 GMT
FT: England 34-12 Papua New Guinea
Steve Sutcliffe BBC Sport
England edged towards a World Cup exit after their points chase against Papua New Guinea descended into a chaotic and error-strewn 34-12 victory that will almost certainly prove insufficient in the final reckoning.
Since their opening loss to Tonga, England's objective had been simple in their two remaining group games. Win and win well to have any hope of the reaching the last four.
They achieved that objective against France with a crushing 82-0 triumph and looked on course to make significant inroads into the 68-point deficit they needed to make up on Samoa when they led 22-0 after 22 minutes, courtesy of tries from Matty Ashton, AJ Brimson, Dominic Young and Harry Smith.
However, things went badly wrong from there on despite head coach Brian McDermott urging his players to the be patient in the build-up to this fixture.
A combination of repeatedly coughing up possession and conceding penalties restored belief in the Papua New Guinea ranks and Dudley Dotoi and Gairo Voro cashed in with tries for the Kumuls as England threw away the initiative.
The sight of England centre Herbie Farnworth being stripped of the ball running towards the try line moments before Mikey Lewis added another try to Morgan Knowles' second-half effort aptly summed up how things had slipped away.
England were guilty of making 21 errors and delivered a performance that included just a 57% completion rate, hardly good enough at this - or any - level.
It was the total opposite of the blueprint from the France game and it means England can now only reach the last four if Tonga defeat Samoa by more than 46 points.
As good as Kristian Woolf's side are, that appears highly improbable given they lost 34-6 to Samoa 12 months ago in Brisbane and have not registered a win over their neighbours since 2018.
I strongly suggest that if it wasn't for the Australian based contingent in the England squad, this could have been even worse. The problem has been created by clubs who lip service to development and use the quota system.
Keith, West Yorks
No surprises with England, their preparation was poor, as the Super League only just finished, they look really tired and off the pace. Maybe this is a wake-up call to the selectors, and Super League in general, but realistically we are miles behind the southern hemisphere teams.
'We go out of this tournament with our heads high'published at 11:18 GMT
11:18 GMT
FT: England 34-12 Papua New Guinea
Retiring Papua New Guinea captain Rhyse Martin on BBC Radio 5 Sports Extra: "I just said to the boys then that I was so proud of their effort. We go out of this tournament with our heads high. We dug in there and we turned it into a game. We were close for a win.
"Shout out to my family and friends, who travelled from around the country to be here tonight. They've been there since day one. The PNG fans are amazing. Good to see so much colour here tonight."
England's Kai Pearce-Paul, player of the match, on BBC Radio 5 Sports Extra: "It was good to get the win. PNG, we knew they were going to be tough and physical. The fans are unmatched and it's a good atmosphere.
"I'm a firm believer in what will be will be. We did what we could today. We'll get together and watch the game and hope it goes our way."
England captain George Williams on BBC Radio 5 Sports Extra: "We were good the first 20 and then the wheels fell off, too many errors. Credit to PNG, they didn't stop fighting. It's disappointing for us - even though we won, a disappointing performance.
"We're feeling pretty rubbish. We're relying on Tonga to do a more than massive job. There's a chance but a very slim one. Gutted."
Unless Tonga do England a massive favour, then this will be the first time ever that there is no British representation in the final four of a men's Rugby League World Cup.
In 16 previous competitions, either Great Britain or England have reached the top four.
That run looks to be over, and is symbolic of just how much the balance of power in world rugby league now lies in the southern hemisphere.
Some very long faces among the England players as they shake hands with the PNG boys.
Blame can be put on a lack of prep time, poor scheduling and the weird format - but tonight's disappointment is all about on-pitch errors, poor decision making and ill-discipline.
Plenty of questions for coach Brian McDermott and captain George Williams.
Robbie Hunter-Paul Former New Zealand international on BBC Radio 5 Sports Extra
There's an element of dissatisfaction. England needed to score 68 points and then any sort of win by Tonga over Samoa would be enough. We were heading in that direction in the opening 40 minutes. They were only falling down by their own mishandling.
The second half, I think it was one of those times where you come it at half-time thinking I've got the opposition, we just need to turn up, put the momentum together and we've got this won.
Robbie Hunter-Paul Former New Zealand international on BBC Radio 5 Sports Extra
How many errors have England made in this second half? They do some great work to get themselves back into position and then a simple carry where they knock-on or lose the ball in a tackle against the ground.
SavalaKnowles 65', substituted for Knowles at 65 minutes
Number
4
4, Farnworth
Farnworth
Number
5
5, Ashton
Ashton
Number
6
6, Williams
Williams
Number
7
7, Smith
Smith
Number
8
8, King
KingHavard 29', substituted for Havard at 29 minutesKing 60', substituted for King at 60 minutes
Number
9
9, Litten
LittenLewis 58', substituted for Lewis at 58 minutes
Number
10
10, Thompson
ThompsonWalters 24', substituted for Walters at 24 minutes
Number
11
11, Nsemba
NsembaWatkins 52', substituted for Watkins at 52 minutes
Number
12
12, Pearce-Paul
Pearce-Paul
Number
13
13, Knowles
KnowlesThompson 52', substituted for Thompson at 52 minutes
Substitutes
home team,England
Number
14
14, Lewis
Lewis
Number
15
15, Walters
Walters
Number
16
16, Havard
Havard
Number
22
22, Watkins
Watkins
Number
21
21, Eckersley
Eckersley
Number
20
20, O'Neill
O'Neill
away team,Papua New Guinea
Starting lineup
Number
1
1, Laybutt
Laybutt
Number
2
2, Derby
DerbyWabo 60', substituted for Wabo at 60 minutes
Number
3
3, Feledy
Feledy
Number
16
16, Mathias
Mathias
Number
5
5, Dotoi
Dotoi
Number
6
6, Voro
Voro
Number
7
7, Biondi-Odo
Biondi-Odo
Number
8
8, Kapinias
KapiniasTaulani 16', substituted for Taulani at 16 minutesMoretti 33', substituted for Moretti at 33 minutesRichard 67', substituted for Richard at 67 minutes
Number
13
13, Horne
HorneMoretti 72', substituted for Moretti at 72 minutes
Number
18
18, Richard
RichardMacDonald 16', substituted for MacDonald at 16 minutesKapinias 56', substituted for Kapinias at 56 minutes
Number
11
11, Martin
Martin
Number
12
12, Put
Put
Number
10
10, Moretti
MorettiGlare 20', substituted for Glare at 20 minutes
SavalaKnowles 65', substituted for Knowles at 65 minutes
Number
4
4, Farnworth
Farnworth
Number
5
5, Ashton
Ashton
Number
6
6, Williams
Williams
Number
7
7, Smith
Smith
Number
8
8, King
KingHavard 29', substituted for Havard at 29 minutesKing 60', substituted for King at 60 minutes
Number
9
9, Litten
LittenLewis 58', substituted for Lewis at 58 minutes
Number
10
10, Thompson
ThompsonWalters 24', substituted for Walters at 24 minutes
Number
11
11, Nsemba
NsembaWatkins 52', substituted for Watkins at 52 minutes
Number
12
12, Pearce-Paul
Pearce-Paul
Number
13
13, Knowles
KnowlesThompson 52', substituted for Thompson at 52 minutes
Substitutes
Number
14
14, Lewis
Lewis
Number
15
15, Walters
Walters
Number
16
16, Havard
Havard
Number
22
22, Watkins
Watkins
Number
21
21, Eckersley
Eckersley
Number
20
20, O'Neill
O'Neill
away team,Papua New Guinea
Starting lineup
Number
1
1, Laybutt
Laybutt
Number
2
2, Derby
DerbyWabo 60', substituted for Wabo at 60 minutes
Number
3
3, Feledy
Feledy
Number
16
16, Mathias
Mathias
Number
5
5, Dotoi
Dotoi
Number
6
6, Voro
Voro
Number
7
7, Biondi-Odo
Biondi-Odo
Number
8
8, Kapinias
KapiniasTaulani 16', substituted for Taulani at 16 minutesMoretti 33', substituted for Moretti at 33 minutesRichard 67', substituted for Richard at 67 minutes
Number
13
13, Horne
HorneMoretti 72', substituted for Moretti at 72 minutes
Number
18
18, Richard
RichardMacDonald 16', substituted for MacDonald at 16 minutesKapinias 56', substituted for Kapinias at 56 minutes
Number
11
11, Martin
Martin
Number
12
12, Put
Put
Number
10
10, Moretti
MorettiGlare 20', substituted for Glare at 20 minutes