Summary

  • Reaction after Premier League confirms Man City guilty of all charges related to breaches of financial rules

  • City arranged "sham contracts" with number of commercial partners as part of scheme to disguise secret funding over more than £830m

  • Statement says City were guilty of majority of charges in relation to its failure to co-operate - but exact figure not given

  • Man City continue to deny any wrongdoing and have until Friday to submit appeal

  • Get Involved: Have you say using the form below

Send us your views

  1. Man City guilty - recappublished at 13:34 BST

    Media caption,

    Man City guilty of 'sham' contracts & misleading accounts

    We brought you all the latest reaction and analysis after it was confirmed Manchester City were found guilty of breaching the Premier League's financial rules.

    We heard from football finance expert Kieran Maguire and former Liverpool managing director Christian Purslow as they helped explain the intricacies of one of the biggest cases in English football history.

    Former players including Micah Richards, Jamie Carragher and Roy Keane also made their feelings clear while former City boss Pep Guardiola also broke his silence on the issue.

    For more of the latest news, analysis and reaction on the topic, keep an eye on the BBC Sport website and app.

    Thanks for tuning in and also for all your messages throughout the day.

  2. Get Involved - 'Clubs and players have been cheating for ever'published at 13:28 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Clubs and players have been cheating for ever. Diving for free kicks and penalties leading to goals which affected promotion, relegation, claiming every throw and corner, professional fouls etc. The Hand of God that went unpunished. City will get the appropriate punishment within the written rules of Premiership membership

    Peter, Wales

  3. Get Involved - 'Blindingly obvious this financial doping was going on'published at 13:26 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Wasn’t it always blindingly obvious this ‘financial doping’ was going on? The real question is how was it allowed to happen at the time and why wasn’t it stopped then?

    Rich, London

  4. 'We will get through this together' - Guardiolapublished at 13:23 BST

    Manchester City Emirati chairman Khaldoon al-Mubarak (L) talks with Manchester City's Spanish manager Pep Guardiola (R) as City players celebrate on the pitchImage source, Getty Images

    In the past few minutes Pep Guardiola, who stepped down as Manchester City manager at the end of last season, has shared a message of support for the club and its fans on Instagram.

    "I want every single Manchester City fan across the world to know I am here; more than ever," Guardiola wrote.

    "I am, always have been, always will, be behind my club, my owner, my chairman, Ferran [Soriano], the players, staff, Enzo [Maresca] and you, our unique supporters.

    "Let me be clear: we will get through this together."

    He added "I love you all" before signing off with a blue heart emoji. His post accompanied a photo of him with City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak among others.

    Guardiola led City to 17 major trophies, including six Premier League titles and a Champions League victory, during his 10-year reign at the club.

  5. Get Involved - 'As a city fan, we've done wrong'published at 13:17 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    As a City fan, we've done wrong. But when you consider what a lot of the money was spent on, just look at the stadium and the sporting facilities available. No other club has achieved that and yet one club is £1.2bn in debt buying players they can't afford.

    Alan, Preston

  6. 'I'd stick my Man City medals in bin'published at 13:14 BST

    Roy Keane, pundit and former player, looks on prior to the FIFA World Cup 2026 qualifier match between England and SerbiaImage source, Getty Images

    Former Manchester United captain Roy Keane has said he would throw his "medals in the bin" if he were a Manchester City player after the club was found guilty of all charges related to breaches of the Premier League's financial rules.

    Keane said the achievements of City's players had become redundant because of the "cheating" that took place during that time.

    "If I was a player, I'd be 100% sticking those medals in the bin. Of course you would, it's cheating," Keane told ITV Sport ahead of England's match against the Czech Republic.

    "They won it on the pitch because cheating was going on."

    And on the club he added: "They knew it would hurt a lot of people, but they've still done it."

    Keane's former United team-mate, Wayne Rooney, however, says his former club do not deserve to be awarded Premier League titles if their city rivals are stripped of them as punishment.

  7. Get Involved - 'Should we not be waiting until we see Man City's irrefutable evidence'published at 13:07 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Should we not be waiting until we see Man City's irrefutable evidence of no wrong doings before we go over the top on what punishments should be handed down?

    Carl, Warrington

    How about the fans of teams that lost to City in the final(s), financially robbed and robbed of a dream. Titles and cups handed to those that lost and relegated to another league. A fine isn't going to appease the wolves!

    Berkley, London

    Everton had 4 points deducted for £35M. City should have 1 point deducted for every £10M. Apply deduction for each following year. If City won by 6 points but only overspent by £50M, then no penalty. If City won by 2 points but overspent by £50 then loose 5 points

    Bill, Hackney

  8. Get Involved - 'Their entire history since 2009 is flawed'published at 13:04 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Without the success obtained during those years, they would have never been able to generate the "genuine" sponsorship and commercial revenue the following years, nor attracting world class players. Their entire history since 2009 is flawed. Harshest punishment possible to be applied here.

    Damien, London

  9. Richards 'devastated' by Man City guilty verdictspublished at 12:58 BST

    Manchester City's English defender Micah Richards celebrates scoring his goal during the English Premier League football match between Manchester City and Newcastle UnitedImage source, Getty Images

    Former Manchester City defender Micah Richards says he felt "absolutely devastated" after reading the Premier League's "damning" guilty verdict on the club's financial charges.

    "The reports were troubling," he said on The Rest is Football podcast. "I saw the words which were used by the Premier League in 'sham contracts' and I felt absolutely devastated.

    "I was at that club since I was 14 years old, I would die for that club. I achieved my dream at Manchester City, but then to hear these reports, and not only me as an ex-player, but the fans, what they have to go through, absolutely devastating."

    While Richards was part of the City's youth academy he lived in 'digs' with a local family who are long-term supporters of the club.

    The 38-year-old, who was part of their title-winning squad in 2011-12, added: "My digs man, he rang me and he was literally in tears and asking me about information, which I don't know. I haven't got the answers to tell him.

    "That's someone who's supported the club for 60-odd years and the uncertainty around it is just heart-breaking. To have a headline of this nature for a club that I love so much, it's been difficult. If you listen to the reports, they are damning.

    "I feel saddened, I feel angry, I feel a little bit confused because, on the other side, you have City's side of the story."

  10. Get Involved - 'Players aren’t responsible'published at 12:54 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    The players aren’t responsible for the sham arrangements. The CEO and the company that owns Man City should be fined and their licences to run the club, possibly revoked including no transfers in for the next 10 seasons.

    Thomas, Farnborough

  11. Get Involved - 'Well done to City'published at 12:53 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    I say well done to City, for highlighting, how bad the Premier League has been ran, when the only teams that could win the league were the clubs that ran it themselves.

    John, Wales

  12. 'If Man City have that smoking gun, why didn't they use it?'published at 12:46 BST

    Tom Bason, football finance expert, joined BBC Radio 5Live to share his thoughts on Man City denying the allegations: "Man City put forward their defence in the court case.

    "They said the league had misunderstood where the money came from, they put forward their case during the investigation.

    "The panel said that City hadn't offered their explanation in the years before.

    "If Man City have that smoking gun, you wonder why they didn't play it during the actual investigation."

  13. Listen to the story behind the Man City chargespublished at 12:39 BST

    BBC Sounds

    If you want to hear the inside story of how the battle between the Premier League and Man City came about, then you can listen to the four-part podcast series on BBC Sounds, presented by Clive Myrie.

    BBC
  14. 'That takes it into a completely different category'published at 12:33 BST

    Yasin Patel, a barrister specialising in sport, spoke to BBC 5 Live about the question of whether Man City were spending their own money: "The way the rules are run - and we have to go back a few years - those football supporters who have seen their clubs close because of debt and overspending will highlight that their clubs fell into that situation. Their supporters and communities suffered because the owners at the time did not have the money, or were taking money out of the club, which they should not have done.

    "Hence why rules were put in place by UEFA back in the early 2000s. Then the Premier League changed its rules so that clubs could have losses of up to £105m.

    "I do sympathise with a lot of fans here. They’re right - we’re all pointing the finger at Man City, apart from those who live in the community and support them. They’ll say, ‘Look at us, we were there.’ These guys have come along and changed everything. They’ve changed Manchester, the blue side, helped the community and put them on the map.

    "There is a point to be made that if they’re putting their own money into the club, and taking money out, it’s their own resources. But there are rules saying they shouldn’t do that, and if they have done that, they should have been open about it.

    "Alternatively, if they haven’t shown the statistics and numbers they should have been showing in terms of auditing accounts, and payments have been hidden, that then takes it into a completely different category.

    "The word ‘fraud’ has been used because they’ve been defrauding, in effect, the auditors and ultimately the Premier League."

  15. 'Man City hierarchy are just gaslighting now'published at 12:26 BST

    Former professional football player and pundit Jamie Carragher ahead of the UEFA Champions League semi-final second leg match between Manchester City FC and Real Madrid at Etihad StadiumImage source, Getty Images

    Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher says he feels sorry both for the Manchester City players and the players of other clubs who missed out on winning trophies.

    “I feel for the players… they’ll almost feel like a lot of their career is going to have an asterisk, or a lot of people will be calling it a sham,” Carragher told Sky Sports.

    “The players were told everything was fine, they would never get done for anything. What the hierarchy are coming out with now, they’re just gaslighting.

    “I think the titles should be taken off their list. Whether other clubs get them is probably slightly different. City have not just hurt their own players.

    “I don’t look at [the medals] years later, but my mind goes back to moments and feelings in my stomach. Those players will never get that feeling and it was robbed by City. No one remembers the medal. Giving trophies or medals back, it doesn’t mean anything. It’s not about medals, it’s about feelings.”

    City are set to face Carragher's former club Liverpool in the league on October 11.

    “Liverpool are probably the biggest losers in all this,” Carragher said.

    “The atmosphere will be electric. In the last five years, Liverpool v City has been ‘the’ game of the Premier League.”

  16. Get Involved - 'The rules are just there to let the established big clubs control the game'published at 12:20 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    The rules are just there to let the established big clubs, especially United, control the game. Blackburn, Chelsea successes would never have happened. It's now stopping Newcastle from competing.

    Anton, Manchester

    All this red cartel nonsense about United Arsenal, Liverpool wanting to dismiss competition through FFP, it was brought in to try to avoid a repeat of the financial decline of Leeds, Portsmouth etc, the first few years of FFP LFC scraped by after the adverse effects of Hicks & Gillett.

    Andy, Scarborough

    Fair to point out that the rules favour established clubs, but equally valid to point out that excessive (and in City’s case, unlawful) investment results in inflated transfers/wages. With costs passed on to consumers. Any punishment will not put right the detrimental impact they’ve caused to the wider game

    JB, Chelmsford

  17. 'The sooner that's applied the better'published at 12:16 BST

    Former Liverpool managing director Christian Purslow, speaking to BBC Radio 5 Live, on what sanctions he would impose: "Let's be really clear, City could not be any clearer in denying these findings.

    "When we finally reach the day of judgement, assuming it gets there, then I think there'll be a three part sanction. The sporting sanction, significant points reductions, it's obviously quite inevitable.

    "The sooner that's applied the better, I think that hangs so damagingly over the league this year.

    "Do Arsenal know as they try repeat their title whether they'll have that outcome affected by their main rival losing points? Do three times trying to stay up now find out it's only two will go down?"

  18. Get Involved - 'The scale of this is almost incomprehensible'published at 12:10 BST

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    The scale of this is almost incomprehensible. The ramifications could be allowed to go on for years (clubs seeking compensation). It is crucial that the sanctions come quickly and are severe in order to cauterise the wound to football.

    Luis, London

  19. 'Clubs will queue up to seek compensation'published at 12:06 BST

    Liverpool Manager / Head Coach Jurgen Klopp (L) exchanges views with Manchester City Manager / Head Coach Josep Guardiola during the Premier League match between Manchester City and LiverpoolImage source, Getty Images

    Former Liverpool managing director Christian Purslow, speaking to BBC Radio 5 Live, on whether he believes they will be stripped of their titles: "I think they probably will be in the case of a guilty verdict but I think the financial element is the second and vital ingredient of a sanction because the second most damaging element of this case is that clubs will be queuing up to seek compensation.

    "There'll be a waterfall of compensation claims that have hung over Manchester City and the league for years. I do favour one, massive fine.

    "I have an idea of a compensation plan where one big settlement is paid into the Premier League, negotiated by City and the league itself, then the league distributes that according to a formula which reimburses people in accordance to the scale of loss they suffered during when City were found to have breached the rules."

  20. Get Involved - 'Points deduction/relegation not big enough punishment'published at 12:01 BST

    I don't think a large points deduction/relegation to the Championship is a big enough punishment. Whatever the punishment needs to keep them out of PL for at least half the time they where cheating. Start back at League One or ban them from promotion to the PL for multiple seasons.

    Cal, Hemel Hempstead

    They were able to sign players they otherwise could not, which is a sporting advantage. Shame for fans and players but it is cheating. Rangers used tax avoidance and ended as tax evasion and couldn't pay. They were liquidated. City can pay but need stripped which Rangers should have been.

    Liam, Newcastle

    Absolutely no point in fining them, they need to be relegated just like Rangers were…. Let's see how quickly the superstars scarper.

    Mark, Spain