Summary

  • A review into UK youth unemployment proposes changes to tax, welfare and education to help get 440,000 young people into work by 2036 - here are the key figures

  • Andy Burnham wants the report, by former minister Alan Milburn, to be a "watershed moment in how we think about welfare and how we support young people", No 10 says

  • The PM today accepted Milburn's case for change, writes our political editor - the government now faces the task of delivering it

  • Milburn suggests businesses should be taxed less for employing young people, and the number of apprenticeships should double

  • The Conservatives say the "lion's share" of what's recommended is a "massive spending plan"

  • Ffion, 24, tells us she is "losing hope" after applying for 100 jobs since June and getting just three interviews, while café owner Ben worries about the costs of taking on young people: "Our margins have been squeezed and squeezed and squeezed"

Are you affected?

  1. Landmark Neets report makes sweeping proposals to change benefitspublished at 18:32 GMT 17 November

    Freya Scott-Turner
    Live reporter

    Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden responding to the Milburn review in the Commons earlierImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    Pat McFadden responded to the Milburn review in the House of Commons earlier

    New Labour veteran Alan Milburn today delivered his long-awaited report into youth unemployment in the UK.

    Almost one million young people aged 16 to 24 (or 13%) in the UK are Neet - not in education, employment, or training. Milburn wants this to fall to around 5% within a decade.

    We knew many of the report's meatiest proposals before today, including that under-25s would no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit, and a proposed cut to the National Insurance rate employers pay for younger workers.

    More detail - which we lay out here - came when the report was released this morning.

    Addressing the House Commons this afternoon, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said the PM’s whole cabinet have endorsed the need for a brand new system.

    He did not give a line-by-line approval about what will be accepted but said a white paper in the new year would set some of this out.

    Shadow secretary of state for work and pensions Helen Whately told the chamber that while she agreed with "plenty" in the review, the "lion's share" of it was a "massive spending plan".

    There's also a lack of clarity about how these recommendations could affect each of the four nations if they are adopted.

    No 10 says it wants this report to be a "watershed moment", but will it enough to reassure many of the young people who have told the BBC how worried they are?

    Ffion, 24, says she's "losing hope" having only secured three interviews out of the 100 applications she's put in. While 20-year-old Eleanor says: "it feels like my entire cohort is on the countdown to becoming Neet."

  2. Milburn gifts Labour MPs a moral argument for welfare reformspublished at 18:24 GMT 17 November

    Chris Mason
    Political editor

    In describing this as a “watershed moment,” the prime minister today accepted Alan Milburn’s case for change.

    The government now faces the task of delivering it. Were ministers to actually manage that, it would amount to one of the most significant shake ups of the welfare state in its history.

    But, Alan Milburn’s proposed timeframe for this stretches to a decade - another geological era in political terms - at least two general elections away.

    Milburn is a deft operator. Tonight, his report now out in the wild, he’s still out and about in Westminster persuading, charming, cajoling; ministers mirroring his language in making their case too.

    And this former MP - still every inch the politician - has an ongoing role; appointed the chair of the new youth opportunities unit. A 68-year-old bloke the first beneficiary of new employment prospects for the young.

    But that glib observation apart, there is a hope within government that Alan Milburn has gifted Labour MPs a moral argument for welfare reforms they can endorse, in other words one not grounded in a directive to make cuts.

    Plus, him hanging around perhaps means he can be a useful lightning conductor for any forthcoming angst on Labour’s benches, as having persuaded them of the big picture mission, the gritty reality of implementing it begins to take shape.

    That, at least, is the strategy within government. We’ll soon see how it actually plays out.

  3. Has the government avoided a political storm? We won't know until it legislates in the new yearpublished at 18:12 GMT 17 November

    Iain Watson
    Political correspondent

    The last time the Labour government attempted welfare reform - under Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves - more than one in four of its MPs forced a retreat.

    The mood on the Labour benches in the House of Commons today was far more upbeat, with some of those former rebels broadly welcoming Alan Milburn’s approach to tackling youth unemployment.

    Government insiders tell me that MPs had been consulted over the proposals, concerns had been listened to (if not entirely addressed) and the Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden had performed a masterclass of political engagement with backbenchers - emphasising support rather than sanctions for young people.

    But it would be wrong to suggest all concerns have been allayed.

    The former Labour shadow chancellor John McDonnell suggested that the rich should be taxed to pay for employment support, rather than some young people facing benefits cuts.

    Another former frontbencher on the Left - Richard Burgon - felt that disabled young people could be forced into poverty if their entitlement to Personal Independence Payments (PIP) was curtailed.

    That said, he also acknowledged there was a lot to welcome in the Milburn report.

    And while some notable former rebels are now willing to give Milburn’s approach a fair wind, it won’t be entirely clear if the government has avoided a political storm until it legislates in the New Year.

  4. Ministers will look at Milburn report in 'real detail'published at 17:59 GMT 17 November

    Andrew Rogers
    BBC Newsbeat presenter

    Skills minister Baroness Jacqui Sith in a green jacket, laughingImage source, PA Media

    We’ve been talking to skills minister Jacqui Smith on Newsbeat this afternoon - who tells us her first job was a part-time one doing washing-up at a local boarding school.

    She says she agrees with Alan Milburn that it’s much harder to get that kind of job in 2026, which makes it harder for people to get the experience they need in the workplace.

    The government agrees it’s “a moral disgrace as well as an economic problem for our country and obviously devastating for the young people that find themselves in that position”, Smith tells us.

    She says they’re going to look at all the report’s recommendations in “real detail” and want to “shift the system so it focuses opportunity and support first".

    We asked Smith what good the report’s recommendations will be to people who will be older than 25 in the next few years and are struggling to find work now.

    She points out the government's previously announced jobs guarantee for eligible 18-24-years olds on universal credit.

    “That’s in operation now, as are the subsidies that we’re paying to employers to take on young apprentices or to give people a chance of a job,” she says.

  5. What could Milburn's review mean for Northern Ireland?published at 17:37 GMT 17 November

    John Campbell
    BBC News NI economics and business editor

    Alan Milburn's review is overwhelmingly focused on England, though important changes are likely to apply in Northern Ireland.

    In his report, Milburn says the underlying causes of youth worklessness apply across the UK.

    Even so, it takes nearly 200 pages before his 278-page report acknowledges that policy levers such as education, skills and health are devolved to Northern Ireland's Executive at Stormont.

    The report urges Stormont and the other devolved administrations in Wales and Scotland to work with Westminster to settle on shared definitions, common targets and regular joint progress reviews.

    You can read more on how the report could affect Northern Ireland in our story.

  6. Listen live to BBC Newsbeat’s second special programmepublished at 17:29 GMT 17 November

    Andrew Rogers
    BBC Newsbeat presenter

    Man in black t shirt in front of shelves

    Earlier on BBC Newsbeat we handed our full 15-minute lunchtime programme to our audience of 15 to 24-year-olds - and their thoughts on the struggle to find, and keep, a job.

    Now we’ll be switching things up at teatime and looking at the things or solutions that might give you hope.

    We’ve got the government’s Skills Minister Jacqui Smith answering questions from Denim, 18, and 22-year-old Ahmed - and telling us what her first job was.

    We’ll also hear from apprentice Reiss, 23, and people from the Republic of Ireland and Denmark about how their countries are getting it right.

    Meanwhile, 22-year-old Dex from Bristol says he agrees with Alan Milburn when he says young people today “are more entrepreneurial than ever” and should be given support to start their own businesses.

    You can listen to the programme live at the top of this page, and on Radio 1, 1Xtra and Asian Network from 17:45 to 18:00.

  7. 'We would jump on a scheme to help us employ young people'published at 17:18 GMT 17 November

    Nick Edser and Simon Browning
    Business reporters

    Ally Fir with her partner Matt
    Image caption,

    Ally and her partner Matt run a bookshop in Westbourne

    One proposal put forward by the Milburn review is to provide cash incentives to employ younger workers.

    Employers who take on any young person who has been Neet for six months should receive a £3,000 payment, and small businesses - with fewer than 50 employees - that do so should receive an extra £2,000, suggests the review.

    There would also be an extra £2,000 payment if the young person has been in care or is disabled.

    Ally Fir runs a bookshop in Westbourne, alongside her partner Matt, and thinks more state support is needed.

    She says incentive schemes for small business "would help us to employ more, especially young people. If a scheme like that was going we'd jump on it right away."

    Fir says she gets job applications "every single day". She'd like to take more people on but "it is the cost of employing people that makes that impossible".

  8. The latest in a series of changes for schoolspublished at 17:02 GMT 17 November

    Hazel Shearing
    Education correspondent

    Many teachers and head teachers will be looking at the recommendations in Milburn’s report and bracing.

    They’ll have noted, in particular, the proposals requiring schools to identify and support pupils at risk of becoming Neet, offer work experience, and roll out writing, numeracy and oracy checks for Key Stage 3 pupils.

    Then there’s the prospect of a new performance measure that will assess them based on what their pupils go on to do.

    The National Education Union, the UK’s biggest teaching union, says Milburn’s recommendations would mean “more tests and targets”, which would inevitably become “high stakes”.

    They would also be the latest set of changes schools need to get to grips with.

    The government has announced changes to the curriculum, an overhaul of the special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) system and new plans for vocational education all within the space of just over a year.

    Now they’ll be working out how it all fits together in practice.

  9. The Milburn review in numberspublished at 16:50 GMT 17 November

    13: The percentage of young people categorised as Neet - that's nearly one million people

    10: The number of years covered by Milburn's plan

    £8.1bn: The current yearly spend on key benefits for young people, which includes £4.7bn on youth health and disability benefits, according to the review

    £125bn: The estimated current cost per year of the UK’s "failure" to address high Neet rates, once lost output, scarring, foregone tax, benefits, health and wellbeing are considered, according to the review

    £500m: The initial investment Milburn is calling for to be available from April 2027 for this plan, with the funds ramping up each year

    Alan MilburnImage source, PA Media

    The costs and savings in 10 years

    £5.8bn: The annual cost of the measures outlined by Milburn by 2036

    £3.6bn: The annual welfare savings estimated by Milburn by then under his plan

    £2.4bn: The estimated annual increase in tax revenue and reduced benefit payments by 2036

    £200m: The estimate for how much Milburn’s plan will save a year by 2036, after which it predicts the yearly savings will keep increasing

    6.8: The percentage of young people forecast to be Neet in 10 years if these proposals are implemented - with Milburn saying potentially higher economic growth and changes to the youth labour market could drive it down to 5%

  10. Which sectors have the most entry-level vacancies?published at 16:39 GMT 17 November

    The sector with the highest average number ofentry-level vacancies in the year to October was teaching, with most of those jobs being for teaching assistants, learning support and cover supervisor roles, according to jobs website Adzuna.

    The next largest was hospitality and catering, traditionally an area where younger people get their first experience of work. Accounting and finance had the third-highest number of job openings.

    This Flourish post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.

  11. Tailor your CV and ask for help: Tips from a job coachpublished at 16:13 GMT 17 November

    Andrew Rogers
    BBC Newsbeat

    Emily TottmanImage source, Emily Tottman
    Image caption,

    Emily Tottman says there is hope out there

    Plenty of people we speak to on BBC Newsbeat tell us they’re fed up of not hearing back from job applications or only hearing negative things.

    Job coach Emily Tottman says that can be really difficult, especially in the age of AI and online applications, and can "dull your motivation".

    Her advice is to get out there "into the world, into workplaces, chatting to employers", which she says can sometimes build a bit of motivation.

    Emily, who works for youth employment charity Spear, advises people to make sure you tailor your CV to individual applications and do cover letters even if they're optional.

    "If you are really struggling and you’re at the point where you’ve applied for hundreds of jobs and you’re not getting an interview, ask for help," she says.

    "Whether from friends or family or from employability programmes that can help you do really good applications, build up your motivation again."

    And Emily’s one message to anyone reading this who might be struggling to find work?

    "There's hope out there, there are job opportunities, you can do it. Just because you've had rejections from employers, you have skills, you do have the confidence to be able to work."

  12. How many young people claim benefits?published at 16:01 GMT 17 November

    Ben Chu
    BBC Verify policy and analysis correspondent

    The Milburn report estimates that around £8bn a year is currently being spent on benefits directly for young people through the welfare system, made up of £4.6bn on Universal Credit and £3.2bn on Personal independence payments (Pip).

    The number of 16-24 year olds in England and Wales claiming the health element of Universal Credit has increased from 105,000 in 2020 to 193,000 this year according to the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

    Young Pip claimants have also increased from 230,000 to 511,000 over that time, while official forecasts suggest this number is set to rise, external, external above 800,000 by 2037.

    This Flourish post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.

  13. It's possible some young people may lose money in the short-term - Milburnpublished at 15:52 GMT 17 November

    Alan Milburn looks to an interviewer off camera as he is interviewed

    Alan Milburn has been speaking to the BBC's education editor Branwen Jeffreys, and it's put to him that he is suggesting some of the costs for his plan should be met by cutting benefits for young people.

    There have to be changes to the benefits system, he says, adding overall too much is being spent on benefits and not enough on employment support.

    But he notes some people - particularly the most disabled - need more support.

    Pressed over what this could mean for people worried about their budgets, he says the changes he has proposed will "take time", with legislation needed.

    But he says the current system is "writing people a short-term cheque" and the best outcome is for people to have a job, saying: "If you're on benefits, by and large, you're not in prosperity, you're in poverty."

    It's put to him that if you are living in poverty then losing even a small amount can have a big impact - to which Milburn says he understands, but argues it has to be looked at through the lifetime of a young person.

    "I fully accept that it's possible that young people, some young people, may lose some money in the short-term. But they will gain more in the medium term because they will be in work. If you're not in work you will never escape poverty," he says.

  14. How political parties have responded to today's proposalspublished at 15:31 GMT 17 November

    Kemi BadenochImage source, PA Media

    Reacting to the Milburn review, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said the government values young people and rejects the narrative that sees them as "snowflakes and skirkers".

    Here's how other parties have responded:

    • Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said her party agrees with Milburn's "diagnosis", and argued that the government has "made the problem much worse for young people" with policies like the national insurance rise
    • Lib Dem treasury spokesperson Daisy Cooper said if the government wants to get people into work, it must back high street firms "that give many their first job", scrap the "unfair jobs tax" and negotiate a new growth and defence partnership with the EU
    • Green Party leader Zack Polanski described Milburn's proposals as "a flimsy sticking plaster" that intend to "slash support for disabled young people while subsidising corporations to hire cheap labour"
    • Reform UK chancellor spokesperson Robert Jenrick claimed Milburn's predicted savings of £200m by 2036 is the equivalent of five hours of welfare spending
  15. A reminder of the key proposals from Milburn's reviewpublished at 15:12 GMT 17 November

    Former Health Secretary Alan Milburn has put forward a range of recommendations to help get more young people back into work, training or education.

    Here's a reminder of what we heard from his report this morning:

    • Employers could be given cash incentives for taking on Neets, such as a £3,000 payment for taking on a young person who has been economically inactive for six months
    • The government should aim to double the number of young people completing apprenticeships over the next decade to "rival university as a mainstream destination"
    • The report recommends a huge expansion in post-18 college places, and targets an extra 150,000 18- to 24-year-olds taking up further education places
    • It suggests lowering employers' National Insurance costs for 21- to 24-year-olds, starting in retail and hospitality, meaning employing those young people would be cheaper
    • An "entirely new benefits system" should be introduced for under-25s. A new youth allowance would be set at the basic rate of Universal Credit for under-25s

    You can read more about the proposals put forward in the report in our story here.

    Alan MilburnImage source, PA Media
  16. Milburn to chair new youth opportunities unitpublished at 14:58 GMT 17 November

    Alan Milburn has been appointed chair of the new youth opportunities unit, the government says.

    Reporting directly to the Prime Minister Andy Burnham, the unit will sit at the centre of government, "driving the cross-system changes needed to deliver greater opportunities and support for young people," according to officials.

    Its responsibilities include working with ministers to reduce Neet rates, and shaping the government's response to today's review.

  17. 'It took dedication and exposure to different things to find out what I'm good at'published at 14:47 GMT 17 November

    Katy McCloskey
    BBC Scotland

    Emily Winters

    Emily Winters left school at 15 without having sat any exams.

    She is now aged 19 and has recently started her first full-time job with Scottish Power.

    Emily, from Glasgow, received help from Enable, a charity which supports people with learning disabilities, their families, and carers.

    She took part in a scheme called Breaking Barriers, sitting in some university classes for a few months and also being given work experience.

    She says this all helped build her confidence, and that she had a good support system.

    “It took dedication and exposure to different things to find out what I’m good at,” she says.

    “I had no idea about the different opportunities out there.

    “It’s not the end of the world leaving school, if that’s not what’s meant for you.”

  18. 'If you're doing an apprenticeship, you're earning, you're learning'published at 14:36 GMT 17 November

    Peter Gillibrand
    BBC Newsbeat

    Ewan Paterson and Reiss Smith in his vis jacketsImage source, Ewan Paterson/ Reiss Smith
    Image caption,

    Ewan Paterson and Reiss Smith both see the value of apprenticeships

    Alan Milburn himself says apprenticeships should be the "largest" priority from his review.

    He reckons the number of people completing one should double in the next decade - and just over a third should have started one by the age of 25 in the same period.

    BBC Newsbeat took a trip to SJ Roberts Construction - which is based in Shropshire and mid-Wales - where almost two in every five staff members are apprentices.

    Ewan Paterson, 22, is one of them and says he thinks more people his age are going for apprenticeships.

    "A lot more people don't want the debt," he says.

    “If you're doing an apprenticeship, you're earning, you're learning.”

    Reiss Smith, 23, is doing a degree apprenticeship at the firm and says a lot of his mates who went to university are "struggling".

    He says it's "definitely" been the right decision for him and hopes there'll be "more of a push" for apprenticeships.

    "There's no uni debt, the practical skills are what's really needed," he says, adding that employers are “after experience and if you can get that early on while learning I think that's invaluable".

  19. BBC Verify

    A Neet rate of 5% would be far lower than seen in recent yearspublished at 14:23 GMT 17 November

    By Tom Edgington

    Alan Milburn has set out a “national ambition” to cut the UK Neet rate, saying that “within 10 years we should aim to get the Neet rate to around 5%”.

    The latest official data, external estimates that 13% of young people aged 16 to 24 in the UK are not in education, employment or training.

    Reducing that rate to 5% would mean bringing it down to a level significantly lower than at any point since comparable records began in 2001.

    According to the Office for National Statistics, external, the lowest recorded Neet rate was 9.7%, between April-June 2021.

  20. 'My entire cohort is on the countdown to becoming Neet'published at 14:11 GMT 17 November

    Rozina Sini
    BBC News

    Headshot of Eleanor PatamiaImage source, Eleanor Patamia

    Eleanor Patamia, 20, is due to graduate from the University of Liverpool next May.

    "It feels like my entire cohort is on the countdown to becoming Neet," she says this morning.

    "We’ve done every employability session, work placement and volunteering opportunity on offer to us, but some of my peers cannot even find part time work to do alongside their degree even with previous work experience."

    Although she says she has always been able to find work while studying, she believes it is becoming more difficult.

    "It feels like the media wants to berate us for choosing to go to university, but it is not our fault that we are graduating with little to no jobs on the market."

    She adds that the proposals outlined today "sound like they will take graduates back to the same level as school leavers" - but believes that a higher level of education should open graduates up to better jobs.

    BBC Your Voice banner - white writings on purple background