Summary

Media caption,
Burnham makes ChatGPT joke as he opens Prime Minister's Questions
  1. Burnham and Badenoch clash over welfare bill and youth unemploymentpublished at 13:58 GMT

    Jacob Phillips
    Live reporter

    Andy Burnham stands at the dispatch box with a folder open in the House of Commons. Cabinet members watch on from the front bench.Image source, House of Commons

    Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch began a bumper 45-minute edition of PMQs by repeatedly asking if Prime Minister Andy Burnham will cut the welfare bill this Parliament.

    Plans to get young people back into work or education will take around 10 years before there is an overall saving for the taxpayer, she said.

    In response, Burnham praised a "landmark report" on youth unemployment and insisted the government was making progress immediately.

    A fiery PMQs session followed as the leaders clashed over their parties' records to help young people.

    Burnham talked up what he called “support and opportunity” and what he characterised as the Conservatives’ “cuts-only approach”, with Badenoch countering that the PM was offering “the vibes of welfare reform” without actually delivering, writes our Political Editor Chris Mason.

    Attention also turned to Brexit and the UK's future relationship with the European Union.

    With a UK-EU Summit taking place in Brussels on Friday it was perhaps inevitable the topic would also feature, adds Mason.

    Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey said he would "ditch" the existing Brexit deal while Burnham said the Conservatives had "burned bridges" with the UK's European neighbours and that he is seeking to rebuild them.

    We are now finishing our live coverage, you can read more in our news story here.

  2. 'There is a possibility' that some young people will lose benefits - ministerpublished at 13:43 GMT

    Vicki Young
    Politics Live presenter

    Will some young people who currently receive benefits see those benefits cut under the government’s plans?

    I asked the government minister Sarah Sackman this question in the Politics Live studio after PMQs – she told me we will have to wait for the government's formal response to Alan Milburn’s recommendations, but that "if young people don’t take up the opportunities that are presented to them, then of course there is a possibility that they will miss out".

    Speaking for the Conservatives Richard Fuller, the shadow chief secretary to the Treasury, rejected Andy Burnham’s characterisation of his party's welfare plan as "crude cuts", telling me Tory leader Kemi Badenoch was focused on cutting taxes for businesses to boost jobs.

    You can catch up with today’s Politics Live on BBC iPlayer

  3. BBC Verify

    Will the Neets plan not deliver any savings for 10 years?published at 13:29 GMT

    Ben Chu, policy and analysis correspondent

    Earlier in PMQs, Badenoch challenged Burnham over the level of welfare savings in the plan to get young people not earning or learning (Neet) into work or education.

    The Conservative leader claimed the prime minister “isn’t planning any savings for 10 years”.

    The Neets plan drawn up by former Labour MP Alan Milburn does include long-term welfare savings, which are projected to be £3.6bn per year by 2036.

    But it includes a lot of up-front spending to help get these young people into work - forecast to be £5.8bn per year by 2036.

    It also estimates the government would reap £2.4bn a year in additional taxes, as more of them would be in work.

    Once that is factored in, you get estimated net savings of just £200m a year in 2036, a relatively small amount and still 10 years off.

    Burnham said “the Milburn report says to reduce the welfare bill, you have to improve support”.

    This Flourish post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.

  4. First impressions from covering PMQs in the Commonspublished at 13:22 GMT

    Angus Thompson
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    A wide shot shows the House of Commons full of MPs. Around a dozen MPs can be seen standing at the end of the chamber opposite the SpeakerImage source, House of Commons

    Watchers either love or loathe the so-called pantomime of PMQs. Depending on who you ask it’s cheap pageantry or part of the zest of democracy.

    The added colour this week came from the PM appearing to take the temperature of Milburn's welfare changes from those behind him, or trying his hand at cementing the re-emerging EU debate as one centring on Tory economic mismanagement.

    As a first-timer in the Commons my impression is that it's a far more textured show of party politics than what I’m used to.

    Australia’s federal parliament, which I used to cover, is a fairly binary affair in which the Opposition hammers home tested lines of attack while government backbenchers are confined to asking questions that bolster their leaders rather than scrutinise them.

    Here backbenchers are keen to demonstrate they’re fighting for their constituencies rather than often just parading the government line.

  5. Government will look at extending NDA protections to freelancers - Burnhampublished at 13:11 GMT

    Burnham speaks in the House of Commons, wearing a suit and tie.Image source, House of Commons

    Burnham says the government will look at extending employment rights protections to freelancers that ban using non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to silence employees over workplace sexual misconduct and discrimination.

    Liberal Democrat Layla Moran welcomes the protections given to employees in the government's Employment Rights Act, but says freelancers and fans "like those targeted by Russell Brand" can "still be silenced", and "it has to stop".

    Reminder: Disgraced comedian Brand was last week sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison for rape and sexual assault.

    Moran asks Burnham if he will meet with her to discuss extending the protections "to everyone" so that the "rich and the powerful can no longer buy the silence of the vulnerable".

    The PM says "NDAs should never be used to silence victims".

    He adds that the government "will go further, we will look at freelancers, and we will do exactly what she says".

  6. Burnham feels 'duty-bound' to help save Jodrell Bank Observatorypublished at 13:06 GMT

    An ariel view shows the Lovell Radio Telescope. The huge structure which resembles a satellite dish towers over nearby fields and treesImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    The government said it was "exploring" long-term options for the Jodrell Bank Observatory, home to the UK's largest telescope in October after its future was put at risk.

    Lib Dem MP Helen Morgan raises the issue of the Jodrell Bank Observatory, which has housed the UK's largest telescope for nearly 70 years but faces closure when funding is expected to cease in April 2028.

    Burnham says as part of a generation of north-west school children who went on trips to Jodrell Bank, he feels "duty-bound" to do everything in his power to save the critical infrastructure.

    For context: The funding body, the UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) agency, said it had to focus investment on projects that deliver "the greatest long-term impact".

  7. Burnham claims Conservatives 'burned bridges' with European neighbourspublished at 13:03 GMT

    Chris Mason
    Political editor

    Andy Burnham looks to his left as he speaks at the dispatch box in the House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Ahead of the UK-EU Summit in Brussels on Friday, it was perhaps inevitable that Brexit - and the UK’s future relationship with the European Union - would feature in today’s exchanges.

    Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey, who regularly leans into his party’s unflinchingly pro-European instincts, said he would “ditch” the existing Brexit deal, known as the Trade and Cooperation Agreement. On Friday Andy Burnham will announce changes to the existing deal.

    The prime minister claims the Conservatives “burned bridges” with European neighbours and he is seeking to rebuild them.

    But he faces a big strategic question after Friday: how noisily and frequently he continues to publicly lean in to the wider conversation, which could include rejoining the EU - as the arguments on all sides notch up.

  8. Three-quarters of an hour for PMQs this weekpublished at 12:57 GMT

    Prime Minister's Questions today have gone on for over 45 minutes - a quarter of an hour over the scheduled 30-minute slot.

    Since becoming prime minister roughly four months ago, Andy Burnham has not been known for his brevity at the dispatch box.

    The session has now finished. Stay with us as we bring you some of the questions the PM took towards the end.

  9. Burnham and Badenoch trade barbs over Neets reviewpublished at 12:55 GMT

    Jacob Phillips
    Live reporter

    Kemi Badenoch speaks at a dispatch box in the House of Commons in front of her front benchers. She is wearing a pink dressImage source, House of Commons

    One topic dominated Andy Burnham and Kemi Badenoch’s exchange at PMQs today: young people.

    The PM thanked former Health Secretary Alan Milburn for his “landmark report” published yesterday, which looked into how to get thousands more young people into education, training or work, and called for all sides of the Commons to get behind the review.

    But Badenoch insisted the government's response to youth unemployment is "yet more kicking things into the long grass" and would take a decade to create savings for the tax payer.

    In a fiery session both leaders exchanged barbs over their parties' efforts to help young people into work and education.

    The volume rose on the government benches as Burnham pointed out that the biggest rise in Neets came between 2022 and 2024 when the Tories were in power. Badenoch countered and blamed the rise on the Covid pandemic before pointing out the Neet rates dropped between 2011 and 2021 under the Tories.

    Burnham later attacked the Conservatives for slashing youth services and trembling tuition fees before calling for the Tories to show some "humility" after leaving almost a million young people "without any hope for their future".

    In return, Badenoch accused Burnham of offering "false hope" to young people and says the cost of employing young people has gone up under the current government.

    As always with PMQs Burnham got the final word, writes our political reporter from the Commons, and accused Badenoch of taking a "patronising tone" and her side of throwing young people "on the scrapheap".

  10. PM faces plea to support fishing industry in face of fuel crisispublished at 12:50 GMT

    Brixham fish market
    Image caption,

    Brixham fishing port and fish market

    Liberal Democrat MP Caroline Voaden is up next.

    She says Brixham - one of South Devon’s sea fishing ports - is the "highest value fishing port in England", yet fishers tell her they can hardly afford to go out to sea any more because of the high cost of fuel.

    One is spending an extra £18,000 a week for his three vessels, she says.

    Voaden tells the PM governments across Europe are supporting fishers and asks whether he will do the same to help them "survive this existential crisis".

    Burnham says: "I will also support our fishing industry and I look forward to having that conversation with them," adding that he has taken action on fuel duty by freezing it in the Budget though he knows there is "probably more that can be done".

  11. Burnham talks up support for young people as Badenoch accuses PM of just offering 'vibes of welfare reform'published at 12:46 GMT

    Chris Mason
    Political editor

    The main exchanges at PMQs were both a reprise of the recent conversations about young people, training and jobs - and an indicator of where the debate prompted by Alan Milburn’s report on the issue is likely to tilt in the new year.

    The essence of the prime minister’s argument - as I wrote this morning - is to attempt to make a moral case for the changes to benefits and support Milburn is advocating.

    Andy Burnham talked up what he called “support and opportunity” and what he characterised as the Conservatives’ “cuts-only approach” with the Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch countering that Burnham was offering “the vibes of welfare reform” without actually delivering.

    “We don’t have 10 years” she argued - in reference to Milburn’s assessment that his plan would take around a decade before there was an overall saving for the taxpayer.

  12. From 'ruthlessness' to 'queasiness': PM fends off SNP barb over EUpublished at 12:43 GMT

    Angus Thompson
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Cutting remarks from SNP's Dave Doogan when trying to make a point about the "ruthlessness" with which Burnham took Keir Starmer's place as PM in contrast to his apparent "queasiness" about his wording around getting closer to the EU.

    Burnham responds by saying he's honoured the "red lines" around the Brexit conversation previously laid out by his predecessor.

  13. Lib Dem leader Ed Davey asks about new Brexit deal with EUpublished at 12:42 GMT

    EU and Union Jack flags fly in front of Big BenImage source, EPA/ Shutterstock

    Ed Davey also pays tribute to former MP David Evennett, who has died this week.

    Turning to Brexit, the Lib Dem leader says the "Vote Leave zombies" are still out in force, as he characterises the Conservatives' UK-EU deal as a "horror" leading to higher taxes and higher bills. He asks if the PM will get a new deal.

    Burnham says the "truth" is the Tory Brexit deal wasn't good enough for Britain. The Conservatives "burned bridges with our largest market", he says.

    The PM says he is looking for support in the Commons for a new deal on that's on the table, which he says can bring growth and lower the cost of the weekly shop.

  14. Davey pushes PM on Nvidia scandalpublished at 12:36 GMT

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Carefully chosen words from Burnham as Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey urges him to speak out against the tripartite meeting between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping.

    Davey focuses in particular on the Nvidia scandal - you can read all about that here.

    The PM edges around that issue, saying he wants to "establish the facts", but says he will be in Berlin on Thursday for a meeting of the "coalition of the willing" as Trump and co. are having their summit.

    Jensen Huang, ex-CEO of NvidiaImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigned from his position this month, after revelations emerged about two affairs he had - one with a woman suspected to be a Chinese spy

  15. Loud jeers as Badenoch offers to 'clear up confusion' for PMpublished at 12:32 GMT

    For Badenoch's last question, she starts by saying she will "clear up some confusion" for the PM - to loud jeers in the Commons - and says that Labour does not understand that the way to reduce youth unemployment is to make it easier for businesses to hire people.

    She says inflation and interest rates are up and asks whether Burnham will agree that his government is not working.

    In response, the PM says growth is up and unemployment is down and - again to lots of energetic jeering in the chamber - describes Badenoch's tone as "patronising".

    He says the Labour government has a vision for growth and want to "lead on Europe", while he accuses the opposition of being "stuck in the politics of the past".

  16. Burnham criticises Tories for a 'decade of low growth' on their watchpublished at 12:29 GMT

    Badenoch goes on to say that the government's response to youth unemployment is "yet more kicking things into the long grass", repeating "we don't have 10 years".

    She says there is a "lost generation" of young poeople going straight onto welfare because jobs are "disappearing".

    She says on Friday Burnham will sign up to a deal with the EU that will allow 100,000 more young people to enter the UK "to compete for those jobs".

    Burnham says creating jobs requires economic growth and criticises the Conservatives for overseeing a "decade of low growth", saying the deal on the table with the EU will bring growth and lower food prices.

    He says the Tories used to back reducing red tape, and says the party is "so split" over EU policy that they "cannot stand up for this country and support a deal that will bring growth".

  17. Clash gets a bit personalpublished at 12:26 GMT

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Badenoch pointedly accuses the PM of not understanding that economic growth comes from business not government.

    This goes down very well on the Tory benches.

    Burnham accuses her of taking a "patronising tone" and says his side "believes in the next generation" and her side of throwing young people "on the scrapheap".

    As always at PMQs, he gets the final word - but Tory MPs will go away happy with her performance.

  18. Burnham is offering 'false hope', says Badenochpublished at 12:25 GMT

    Kemi BadenochImage source, House of Commons

    Badenoch says Burnham is offering "false hope" to young people, describing his Youth Guarantee scheme as a failure. The Tory leader says the government destroys jobs, then offers businesses a little money to give people work placements - "it makes no sense at all".

    She says hardworking taxpayers are losing out because of "Labour's welfare bill", and says the cost of employing young people has gone up under this government.

    Badenoch asks: Why won't the PM cut what she calls the "jobs tax" on young people?

    Burnham responds by saying unemployment is down and the fundamentals of the British economy are strong.

    The government is considering its response to the Milburn review, he says, but it won't follow a "cuts only" approach.

  19. PM pledges 'hope and a better life' for young people getting into workpublished at 12:21 GMT

    Burnham in House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Badenoch counters that when the Conservatives were in government between 2011 and 2021, the Neets rate fell by 7% - and, she says, it went up because of Covid.

    "We did more during our time in government than he [Burnham] is proposing now," she says.

    The Tory leader asks whether individuals will lose money through the proposed changes in the Milburn review.

    Burnham responds that his government is about "helping young people into work...hope and a better life", adding that Conservative MPs need to show some "humility" for leaving almost one million young people "without any hope for their future".

    He attacks the Tories for slashing youth services, cutting education maintenance allowance, and trebling tuition fees: "They took hope from a generation; we will give it back to them."

  20. Cheers on the Labour benches as Burnham accuses Tories of Neet failurespublished at 12:16 GMT

    Angus Thompson
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Volume is rising from the government benches, with cheers going up as Burnham points the finger across the aisle for the level of young people out of work.

    "We will give young people hope," he says after accusing the Tories of making 250,000 young people Neet under its policies.