Who are the Elliot sisters?

Part ofIYKYK

All about Persuasion

Persuasion was the last full-length novel Jane Austen wrote. It was published six months after her death in 1817, having been completed shortly before her death in 1817 at the age of 41.

It might be one you haven’t heard of before. While it’s been adapted for the screen fewer times than titles like Pride and Prejudice, Emma and Sense and Sensibility, Persuasion is still one of Austen’s best-loved stories.

With a new BBC adaptation, The Other Elliot Sister, recently announced, we thought we’d take a look at this less well-known work: what is it about, who are the characters and what are the main themes?

Here, BBC Bitesize breaks down everything you need to know.

A portrait of author Jane Austen. We can only see her head and shoulders. She's wearing a high-neck dress and a lace bonnet, and is looking off to the left with a faint, closed-lipped smile.
Image caption,
Jane Austen was engaged for just one day in 1802, ultimately turning down a match that would have given her financial security and a large estate.

What is Persuasion and what is it about?

Persuasion follows the Elliot family, members of the landed gentry whose pride and overspending have led them into financial difficulty.

The main culprit for this is Sir Walter Elliot, a baronet obsessed with his own appearance and noble lineage. Having ignored his mounting debts for as long as possible, his family is now forced to move to Bath while they rent out their ancestral home.

The novel focuses predominantly on Anne Elliot, the middle of Sir Walter’s three daughters, and her romance with Captain Frederick Wentworth, a naval officer. Eight years before the story begins, Anne was engaged to Wentworth but was persuaded to break it off by her godmother. She’s regretted her decision ever since.

Who are the Elliot sisters?

A still from the TV show The Other Bennet Sister. It shows all five Bennet sisters dressed in empire-waisted Regency dresses and bonnets, carrying small purses. Jane and Lizzie are stood together to the left with their arms linked, Lydia and Kitty are stood together with their arms linked off to the right, while Mary is stood behind them and in the middle, on her own.
Image caption,
The Other Bennet Sister told the imagined story of Mary Bennet, the often-overlooked sister of Elizabeth Bennet from Pride and Prejudice.

However, The Other Elliot Sister won’t focus on Anne. The series will be based on a forthcoming novel by Janice Hadlow, author of The Other Bennet Sister, which was adapted for television in 2025. It follows Mary Bennet, the often-overlooked third sister in Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.

Both the novel and the series will explore Elizabeth Elliot's story. In Persuasion, Elizabeth is Sir Walter’s eldest daughter, and obviously his favourite. Like her father, she’s vain and a bit of a snob, remaining unmarried and becoming his social companion.

Mary Musgrove, the youngest Elliot sister, is married and has two young sons. She is highly-strung, a hypochondriac and often self-absorbed, mistreating Anne by using her to help manage her household and take care of her children.

Anne herself is quiet, sensible and observant. Now 27 and considered past marrying age, she has spent the last eight years in love with Captain Wentworth while doing what others tell her to and struggling to find her own voice. As the novel progresses, we see Anne learn to put herself and her own happiness first.

Since The Other Elliot Sister’s adaptation was announced, there’s been some controversy online over whether Elizabeth really is the most overlooked of the three sisters. Elizabeth features much less in the plot of Persuasion than Anne and Mary, and by the end, she hasn't experienced any real personal growth. But some readers have argued that, when it comes to the Elliots’ family dynamics, Anne herself is really treated as ‘the other Elliot sister’.

For example, Sir Walter and Elizabeth regularly ignore her opinions, treat her like a servant and sideline her at social events. She ‘had been always used to feel alone in the world,’ as the novel states. Meanwhile, Mary is convinced she is the overlooked sister, declaring towards the end of the story that she is ‘always the last of [her] family to be noticed’.

What do you think?

A still from the TV show The Other Bennet Sister. It shows all five Bennet sisters dressed in empire-waisted Regency dresses and bonnets, carrying small purses. Jane and Lizzie are stood together to the left with their arms linked, Lydia and Kitty are stood together with their arms linked off to the right, while Mary is stood behind them and in the middle, on her own.
Image caption,
The Other Bennet Sister told the imagined story of Mary Bennet, the often-overlooked sister of Elizabeth Bennet from Pride and Prejudice.

Who wrote Persuasion and when is it set?

As mentioned above, Persuasion was published posthumously in December 1817 along with Northanger Abbey, which Austen had written much earlier in the 1790s. She had already published Sense and Sensibility (1811), Pride and Prejudice (1813), Mansfield Park (1814) and Emma (1815).

Austen never saw her own name on any of her novels. She wrote anonymously, with Sense and Sensibility signed ‘By A Lady’ and subsequent works credited to ‘The author of Sense and Sensibility’. However, Austen’s friends, family and local community knew her identity, and her brother Henry revealed her real name after her death.

All of her novels, including Persuasion, are contemporary – meaning they’re set at roughly the time they were written. In Austen’s case, that was the Regency period, the time from February 1811 to January 1820 when the future King George IV was ruling as Prince Regent on behalf of his father, George III. Many other beloved novels and period dramas are set in this period, including Netflix’s Bridgerton, adapted from Julia Quinn’s novels.

Born in Hampshire in 1775, Austen’s life and writing took place against the backdrop of political and social upheaval including the French Revolution, the Napoleonic Wars and the start of the Industrial Revolution, as well as clear divides between the extravagance of the aristocracy and the poverty of the working classes.

Persuasion takes place predominantly in the south-west of England. The Elliots move from their family home – Kellynch Hall in Somerset – to Bath. Anne also spends time at Uppercross, a neighbouring village where Mary lives with her family, and Lyme Regis, a coastal town in Dorset.

It actually went by a different title while Austen was writing it – The Elliots. But she didn’t like it and hadn’t settled on a final title before she died. Her brother Henry chose Persuasion when he was arranging for it to be published. Henry had acted as Austen’s informal literary agent, helping her negotiate terms with publishers and promoting her books in his social circles. The naval careers of two of their other brothers, Charles and Francis, also influenced the novel.

What are the key themes in Persuasion?

A landscape image of the Bath skyline. Some of the landmarks include the Gothic Bath Abbey and the Roman baths.
Image caption,
Jane Austen lived in Bath for five years. Her experiences there influenced Persuasion and Northanger Abbey.

As the novel’s title suggests, one of its core themes is persuasion and influence. The central conflict – Anne’s rejection of Captain Wentworth and his reappearance in her life eight years later – asks us whether it’s better to be open to others’ suggestions or to be firm in our own convictions.

Speaking of Wentworth’s reappearance, the novel also features a second-chance romance. Persuasion is widely considered the earliest example of this plot device. It’s unusual for Austen’s work, which tends to feature younger protagonists of conventional marrying age who have never met their love interests before. It’s influenced several well-known works of film and literature, including The Notebook.

Social class is at the heart of why Anne initially broke off their engagement. Her status-obsessed father and godmother, Lady Russell, believed Wentworth was beneath Anne because he had no fortune. By the time they meet again, the Elliots have fallen on hard times and Wentworth is a wealthy, decorated naval hero.

Austen, who never married, also explores themes of gender and marriage in Persuasion. Sir Walter’s preoccupation with Wentworth’s status, or lack thereof, reflects how the Regency gentry treated marriage as an economic contract. But, while women had fewer options than men when it came to securing their future – for example, Wentworth is able to travel and make a name for himself in the navy, while Anne’s value is mainly as a caretaker for her family – the relationship they eventually rebuild is based on mutual respect and equality.

We see this in several of Austen’s happy endings, including Elizabeth Bennet and Mr Darcy and Emma Woodhouse and Mr Knightley. Much like with her commentary on social class, Austen isn’t calling for a revolution, but she seems to be suggesting a better way forward.

A landscape image of the Bath skyline. Some of the landmarks include the Gothic Bath Abbey and the Roman baths.
Image caption,
Jane Austen lived in Bath for five years. Her experiences there influenced Persuasion and Northanger Abbey.

How many times has Persuasion been adapted?

A close-up image of Dakota Johnson's face. She is standing side-on to the camera but looking back at us over her shoulder, smiling. She has long dark brown hair and a fringe.
Image caption,
Dakota Johnson played a modernised, sarcastic version of Anne Elliot in the 2022 Netflix adaptation of Persuasion.

These themes have endured ever since Persuasion’s 1817 publication. The novel has been adapted for the screen several times, first as a BBC miniseries starring Daphne Slater in 1960. Episodes of this adaptation are now considered lost, but another BBC miniseries followed it in 1971, this time starring Ann Firbank and Bryan Marshall.

Next came a film in 1995, directed by Roger Michell. With Amanda Root as Anne and Ciaran Hinds as Captain Wentworth, it won five BAFTAs and was praised for being faithful to the Regency setting. Another film adaptation was released in 2007, starring Sally Hawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones, which is considered more dramatic and less faithful to the novel.

Perhaps the most controversial adaptation is the 2022 Netflix film directed by Carrie Cracknell, starring Dakota Johnson, Cosmo Jarvis and Richard E. Grant. The film modernised the story into a comedy that often broke the fourth wall – meaning characters acknowledge the audience, speak directly to the camera or recognise they’re part of a fictional world.

Instead of being quiet, patient and melancholy, Anne was reimagined as sarcastic and outspoken, openly mocking her family. Some viewers also criticised what they saw as anachronistic dialogue. For example, Anne refers to Wentworth as her ‘ex’ and describes herself as an ‘empath’. However, the film was praised for its visuals, set design and soundtrack.

A close-up image of Dakota Johnson's face. She is standing side-on to the camera but looking back at us over her shoulder, smiling. She has long dark brown hair and a fringe.
Image caption,
Dakota Johnson played a modernised, sarcastic version of Anne Elliot in the 2022 Netflix adaptation of Persuasion.

When will The Other Elliot Sister be released?

Persuasion has also sparked retellings. One, aptly called Modern Persuasion, was released in 2020. Set in New York City, it follows career-focused Wren Cosgrove, who was persuaded to turn down Owen Jasper because he didn’t have stable career prospects.

We don’t know much about The Other Elliot Sister yet, but we do know it will take place in Persuasion’s Regency setting. Production is expected to begin in 2027, with the BBC series consisting of ten episodes. There’s no official release date or cast yet, but Janice Hadlow’s companion novel of the same name will be released in September 2027.

In the meantime, there’ll be three special episodes of The Other Bennet Sister to tide us over. The specials will be released over the Christmas period, and will pick up where series one left off – with Ella Bruccoleri, Donal Finn and Ruth Jones all returning.

This article was first published in November 2026.

Learn more about classic literature