Wharton, Mateta, Esse - fans on who Palace should keep, sell and loanpublished at 11:56 BST 11 June


We asked for your views on who you would keep, sell and loan out from the current Crystal Palace squad this summer.
Here are some of your comments:
Keith: One to loan out - Romain Esse. He needs to build his confidence. Still on for the first team future. One to keep - Adam Wharton. Keep him for another year to see us through the Europa League. His value will increase. One to lose - Brennan Johnson. Hopeless case. We should never have bought him. Lightweight, that just doesn't fit.
Moggy: Sell Jean-Philippe Mateta. I've loved watching him but it's time. Bring back Matheus Franca, who's been exciting to watch on the few occasions we've seen him, as well as Jesurun Rak-Sakyi who has spent enough time out on loan and done well. Loan out Esse again. We paid good money for him but another season may help with whatever caused him to be sent out on loan in the first place.
Simon: Sell: Mateus Franca. Loan: Romaine Esse. Give a chance: We have five young players who should be given a chance now - Danny Imray, Owen Goodman, Tayo Adaramola, Jesurun Rak-Sakyi, David Ozoh - Imray would be my choice. Excelled in the Championship.
Lucy: Keep - Esse. He had a decent loan period last season with Coventry, and hopefully gained the confidence he needed to match the potential he has. (Also please can we keep Evann Guessand permanently? What a brilliant addition to the team he's been!) Loan: Justin Devenny. Get him some game time elsewhere to build on what he showed in the 2024-25 season. Sell: Borna Sosa. Seems like a good guy with great team spirit, but hasn't performed for us.
Manny: Keep: Adam Wharton at all costs. Consistently excellent and at the heart of the side at their best. Loan: Any of the academy lads who have spent too much time on the first team bench. Let's see what they can do and what pathways there are. Sell: Is it too early to say Brennan Johnson? At the same time, the squad is so small that retention and recruitment is key.
Stephen: Keep - Munoz/Lacroix/Wharton - under all circumstances. Loan - Rio Cardines - To see what he really has, he needs minutes. Sell - Mateta. He clearly wanted to go, try to get the best money for him and move on. I suspect we already have his replacement in Jorgen Strand Larsen.
Sean: We should keep Justin Devenny - he has been excellent when called upon, but needs to push a bit harder to become a first team regular. Loan out Caleb Kporha for more playing experience and sell Brennan Johnson - who has been totally anonymous after his big-money move.






















