
Inside the Sentencing Crisis
What is a reasonable punishment for committing a crime? Phil Maguire investigates whether public attitudes to justice match the penalties handed out in courts across the country.
On an August afternoon in 2024, a man walked into a chemist’s shop in Bristol, asking to speak to the pharmacist. When the 75 year-old pharmacist moved from behind the counter to the customer area, the man grabbed him from behind, put a hypodermic needle to his neck and told him he would infect him with AIDS unless he was given methadone – a prescribed heroin substitute. Another customer immediately went outside and gathered a group of workmen who were working nearby to confront the man. The man dropped the needle and left. He was arrested in the early hours of the following morning.
What would we consider to be a reasonable punishment for this crime?
This is one of dozens of sentencing decisions that take place every day in courts across the country.
The judge needs to ensure the victim feels that justice has been done, but different victims may feel more punitive or merciful. They also need to ensure punishments are fair and proportionate. And they need to ensure that public safety is maintained. Judges need to consider how best to help the perpetrator to stop harmful patterns of behaviour, and perhaps go on to be a good citizen, a good parent, a good son or daughter.
And on top of all of this, we need to consider the cost. Reoffending costs an estimated £23 billion each year. Imprisonment is expensive.
Journalist Phil Maguire heads out across the country to talk to people about our response to crime as he aims to understand the intense emotions we all feel when someone causes harm.
Presenter: Phil Maguire
Producer: Beth McLeod
Assistant Producer: Bridie Trotter
A Prison Radio Association production for BBC Radio 4
On radio
Broadcasts
- Tue 15 Dec 202620:00BBC Radio 4
- Wed 16 Dec 202611:00BBC Radio 4
Podcast
![]()
File on 4 Investigates
File on 4 Investigates: News-making original journalism.

