5. The Glass Elevator
Telethon 92 presenter Mik Scarlet learns the hard way what the ‘social model’ is.
Telethon 92 presenter Mik Scarlet learns the hard way what the ‘social model’ is.
Meanwhile, the ‘Rights Now’ campaign, a coalition of organizations calling for disability rights is gaining support and a young lawyer called David Ruebain finds himself at the very heart of it.
Presenter: Sophie Morgan
Assistant Producer: Niall Strawson
Original music and sound mix: Julian Corrie
Series Producer: Sarah Shebbeare
A BBC Studios production for BBC Radio 4
Transcript available on the programme website
On radio
Episode 5 Transcript
MIK: I'm still working, I'm still going to events and things and I'm meeting more and more disabled people to seem to really hate me.
And it became really scary because they didn't hold back. It was truly terrifying.
SOPHIE: I'm Sophie Morgan, and for BBC Radio 4 and The History Podcast, this is ' For Pity's Sake' . The story of how a gang of mavericks from different walks of life came together to fight for disability rights in the UK.
Episode Five, "The Glass Elevator."
MIK: I was doing it because I thought I was doing something good. So I was shocked at that not being able to be seen. And also just the sheer level of anger.
Mik Scarlet was a disabled presenter who'd fronted ITV's coverage of the 1992 Telethon.
It kind of was a, an era where I got really scared.
SOPHIE: A fundraising event for the disabled that - unbeknownst to Mik at the time - Many disabled people despised.
Gill: People from all over the country came on this demonstration against the telethon We disabled people. We know the harm that this does. We don't want this. We don't want your charity. What we want is rights.
DAVID: these were awful things. because they played into and perpetuated this idea that we were, benighted tragic victims.
SOPHIE: And in 1992, through protesting the event disabled activists got the telethon canned
MIK: so I was terrified of them and of their ability to mess my career up and also I kind of didn't get it.
To them my actions had been as I was called regularly, uh, traitorous. So, uh, yeah, it wasn't a great time, I must admit. but it did lead to one of those moments in your life where your life changes.
At the peak of this level of hostility, I was at a big channel four, how to get more disabled people into the media event. and people had been very hostile. Uh, so when it ended, I obviously thought, right, I'm going to run away quickly. I'm not gonna stay around because I think they might actually lynch me.
So I went to rush to get into a lift. this is a big glass elevator in one of those big posh buildings And I wheeled in and behind me, one of the very sort of vocal, campaigners. Uh, a wonderful woman called Vicki Waddington, who is sadly no longer with us, followed me in on a giant scooter, which meant the lift was now completely full and I couldn't get out. She was very glamorous, very confident, and she blocked the door.
So she turned to me and said, you don't know why we were all so angry with you. Do you? I turned around and I honestly went, no, I don't. I was like close to tears. I was so frightened and she then proceeded to teach me the social model of disability.
so we go down the lift, the door opened and she just pressed the button to close and go back up again. So I thought, oh, I'm not getting out then.
Um, and we'd arrived back on the floor where all the other disabled people were waiting to get out and she just turned and went, wait. And then the door shut. And then we went down and we did this quite a few times 'cause it's quite difficult to explain the full meaning of the social model in one lift journey.
The social model says people are disabled not by their bodies or conditions but by society’s lack of access and attitudes. If the barriers were removed, disabled people wouldn’t be excluded.
MIK: And I went in that lift, one person thinking I kind of understood what it was like to be disabled and thinking I was doing something good for my community and not understanding why they hated me so much and came out an entirely different person. because when you learn about the social model, it is life changing for disabled people to understand that you are not broken you are not something less. You are actually just like everybody else. And the reason why you can't do things is because of the way society thinks about you, treats you and the way the world is designed, This isn't about, soldiering through, um, or the superhero model like I'll be the most amazing disabled person you've ever met, and I will battle to be as good as someone who isn't disabled The social model says, no, let's remove the barriers, remove the negativity. There's nothing wrong with being disabled and we have the power to change things.
And that was life changing.
I think for anyone that becomes disabled, there's a level of guilt that goes with it because you can think of all the things that your family has to do or has done differently because of you, and that's your fault because that's how society frames it.
and for me, um, when I was seven, my father died of a heart attack and everybody used to say to me as a 7-year-old that, uh, my dad had died because of all the pressure and stress of having me. Um, so I grew up basically blaming myself for my father's death and for the grief my mum felt and all this kind of stuff.
and that lift journey with Vicki changed my life because by telling me what she did, she set me free of that guilt. I was really, really angry and I came out the lift, probably more angry with the world than anybody waiting for the lift was with me, and it meant I totally instantly saw why they were angry.
MIK: And so probably from that day forth and not for a career furthering reason at all, I have spent my entire life apologizing for the Telethon and trying to spread the word.
In a way it was worth doing because it led to the rest of my life. But I must admit, if I knew then what I know now, I wouldn't have been there.
SOPHIE: I remember when I first found out about the social model, it was like a switch flipped, and I stopped seeing my disability as the problem and started to see the world around me as the problem.
But it took years, just as it did for David Rubain.
DAVID: I had thought that all of the difficulties in my life was because I happened to be disabled and I became very, vexed and even angry and, perturbed about systems and structures, which would put people in boxes in the way that I had been put in a box,
SOPHIE: We've met David before in this series. As a child, he was sent off to a segregated special school for the disabled he describes as little more than warehousing.
Our lives were seen principally as tragedies there wasn't any sense of, expectation of a life fully lived. David left special school at 16 with two grade C O levels, but against all the odds, he got himself to university, Oxford University.
DAVID: during university I was introduced into what's become known as the disability movement, which is the, organizations of and for disabled people who had grown and developed in light of what became known as the social model of disability, which was essentially an understanding that, our lives were inhibited as much, if not more, by, society structures and systems as they were because of our impairments, and I also became undaunted you know, clearly there are lots of things I can't do, but I got this possibly arrogant sense that there's nothing I couldn't do and therefore I did it.
I wanted to do something about, the experience of disabled children given my early life i, saw that the law was being used innovatively to affect social change and I became a lawyer for that reason.
SOPHIE: David's decision to become a lawyer would be pivotal. While the likes of Barbara Lisicki, Alan Holdsworth, and Sue Elsgood, the organizers of the Telethon demo, , who we met in our last episode, were busy running a campaign based around fearless civil disobedience, breaking rules to make themselves heard, another gang of people were lobbying For new rules, rules that would put an end to discrimination.
AGNES: After that experience, with the block telethon, demo, I really began my sort of full-time work, on disability rights.
SOPHIE: For Agnes Fletcher, like so many others, the experience of standing at the barricades of the 1992 Telethon changed everything.
AGNES: Suddenly with this, moment, this jolt I had a shared purpose with, other people, and I had some real clarity disabled people were profoundly discriminated against and unequal. Um, and that led to my interest in the campaign for, legislation that would actually make discrimination against disabled people, illegal
SOPHIE: Agnes joined Rights Now, a coalition of dozens of organizations calling for a change to the law.
AGNES: It was about the difficult business of, drafting what that legislation would look like, the research, the lobbying, the long hard slog of proving to parliamentarians and to others, that legislation could work.
You had, lots of people feeding in, to the legislation, but there were two people who were absolutely core to shaping, the legislation around disability rights. both of them, lawyers, both of them disabled people, both of them, big, big brains who were able to take the frustration and the activism and the sort of sense that things must change and things are, not right. Caroline Gooding, sadly no longer with us, and , David Rubin, who absolutely still is
DAVID: I feel in many ways I was lucky 'cause I was the right person at the right time.
I was around at a time when I was able to make a difference, the thing is, so much of my early life was about people being delighted with me because I managed to turn a light switch on or something. and so I shrink very much from this idea of any kind of view that any of us are heroes as much as I shrink from being a victim.
SOPHIE: I suppose it's true that my skills as a lawyer proved useful to some extent for the Disability Rights Movement at the time. And I became, vice Chair of the Rights Now campaign,but that battle for legislation, it isn't straightforward.
DAVID: There were a variety of attempts during the 1980s to, put forward various versions of legal protection against discrimination and for inclusion,
SOPHIE: but they all failed because the government of the day, decided for various reasons that they would not support such legislation. The reasons included at different points that there wasn't any, evidence of any discrimination. Um, or if there was evidence of discrimination, it would be too complicated to legislate against it or even too expensive. so there was a whole range of reasons that were put forward as to why civil rights legislation should not be enacted to protect, disabled people.
But one country was leading the way.
ARCHIVE: This historic act is the world's first comprehensive declaration of equality for people with disabilities.
SOPHIE: In 1990,
DAVID: in the US they passed, the Americans with Disabilities Act, which was a substantial piece of anti-discrimination legislation.
ARCHIVE: every man, woman and child with a disability can now pass through, once closed doors into a bright new era of equality, independence, and freedom.
DAVID: And so we already had in another country, at least an example of civil rights for disabled people. And so it became increasingly difficult for them, but they continue to resist.
SOPHIE: pressure was mounting on the government, and since the 1992 Block Telethon demo, public opinion was shifting too.
DAVID: I support them a hundred percent. I think they got a good point all I want is for young children who are disabled not to have the the prejudice, lack of access to services. I reckon they're brilliant.
SOPHIE: and by 1994, things are about to come to a head. The disability movement is rapidly becoming unstoppable.
ARCHIVE: When I left special school at 16, for me, being disabled was a source of shame because that's what everybody had told me and, that sort of stayed with me considerably.
But through my meeting of other disabled activists in the eighties. and my coming into the movement and my leadership to some extent of the movement, I was able to have a different relationship, both with other disabled people and with myself. We weren't victims, we weren't tragic. We were, I dunno, justice Warriors or whatever you wanna call us, really.
SOPHIE: next time on For Pity’s Sake.
Gill: The police came along, they got their bolt cutters, they cut through the handcuffs.
Carlo Salvatore: you are having to deest me because your vehicles are inaccessible,there was such a feeling of unity,
That was intensely moving unbelievable feeling. There's nothing quite like it.
Broadcast
- Friday13:45BBC Radio 4
Podcast
![]()
The History Podcast
For Pity's Sake. The extraordinary story of a group of maverick campaigners.

