Summary

  • Angela Constance makes a ministerial statement on NHS Grampian in light of a damning report on its leadership

  • She told Holyrood an "external intervention support team", comprising experienced senior NHS leaders, will work alongside Grampian's health team to provide "intensive turnaround support"

  • Ahead of that statement, backbench MSPs questioned the First Minister on issues concerning their constituents

  • Swinney says he welcomes the Milburn review into tackling the issue of young people not in education, training or work

  • He says Scotland is already on the right road to change, citing the "No one left behind" approach and the growth in vocational qualifications

  1. Goodbyepublished at 16:00 GMT 17 November

    That's the end of our live page coverage of the ministerial statement on NHS Grampian.

    • Angela Constance, the cabinet secretary for health, told Holyrood she was stopping short of escalating the health board to the highest level of government intervention
    • She said that it was an "unacceptable failure" that paediatric surgery continued at Dr Gray's Hospital despite instructions to stop
    • And she said the health board would now receive an "unprecedented" level of support from senior NHS experts, led by the deputy chief executive of NHS Lothian.
    • The statement came after a report into NHS Grampian by Healthcare Improvement Scotland identified systematic issues and recurring weaknesses.

    This live page has been written by Ken Banks and edited by Nichola Rutherford.

  2. 'This has to be the line in the sand'published at 16:00 GMT 17 November

    Angela Constance speaking in Holyrood
    Image caption,

    Angela Constance said it was a time for change

    Health Secretary Angela Constance says the critical NHS Grampian report has to be "the line in the sand".

    She was responding after MSP Emma Roddick said it was clear what was needed was "leadership".

    Constance said the point about leadership was well made.

    "This has to be the line in the sand for Dr Gray's, and also for Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, and NHS Grampian as a whole," she said.

    "This has to be a catalyst for change."

  3. What did the critical report about NHS Grampian say?published at 15:47 GMT 17 November

    Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin.
    Image caption,

    Surgery issues at Dr Gray's in Elgin were highlighted

    A reminder that the Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) report into NHS Grampian identified systemic issues and recurring weaknesses.

    These included:

    • A loss of confidence in management to deliver reliable and consistent information after Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin continued to operate on children despite an order to halt all paediatric surgery
    • Serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across NHS Grampian, including a lack of workforce plans, poor recruitment controls, and significant concerns in how doctors are managed
    • A failure to fix problems on patient safety at NHS Grampian, including concerns of staff not working well together
    • A failure to deal with concerns about safety and quality of care at NHS Grampian's board, including not ensuring services run as well as possible

    Dr Simon Watson, medical director at HIS, described the report on NHS Grampian as "the most serious review" the healthcare watchdog had ever written.

    He told BBC Scotland News the findings were "unprecedented".

  4. Has a Scottish health board been at stage five before?published at 15:42 GMT 17 November

    Aberdeen Royal Infirmary photographed from the airImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Aberdeen Royal Infirmary is NHS Grampian's largest hospital operation

    Constance said NHS Grampian would not be escalated to stage five - the highest level of government intervention - but it remains on the table.

    NHS Tayside was the first Scottish health board to experience similar measures, eight years ago, in response to concerns about its financial sustainability and weaknesses in its governance arrangements.

    The Scottish government describes stage five, external of its framework as a statutory intervention.

    This is where the “level of risk and organisational dysfunction is so significant that the NHS board requires direct intervention”. This power to step in is only used in exceptional circumstances.

  5. External experts to support NHS Grampianpublished at 15:31 GMT 17 November

    Constance said the health board would receive an “unprecedented" level of support from senior NHS experts.

    The team will be led by Jim Crombie, deputy chief executive of NHS Lothian.

    He will be supported by Chris Deighan, former medical director of NHS Lanarkshire; Pamela Johnston, former medical director of NHS Tayside; and Kay Fawcett, who was part of the HIS diagnostic review team and has held a number of nurse director roles in NHS trusts in England.

    Healthcare Improvement Scotland will also be asked to complete an early review of NHS Grampian within three months to assess progress, followed by ongoing reviews.

  6. Dr Gray's surgery continuing was 'unacceptable failure'published at 15:29 GMT 17 November

    Paediatric surgery continued at Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin despite instructions to stop, the HIS report revealed last week.

    Angela Constance said the instruction was given in June - but was not implemented until August.

    "That is an extremely serious and wholly unacceptable failure," she said.

    She only learned about the situation through the media, she told Holyrood.

    "Information was not being openly or properly shared or escalated to or by the board," she added.

    "So, it’s vital that change happens now."

  7. Maximum government intervention at NHS Grampian still an optionpublished at 15:17 GMT 17 November

    Lisa Summers
    BBC Scotland health correspondent

    Angela Constance
    Image caption,

    Angela Constance said NHS Grampian would stay at level four

    Health Secretary Angela Constance has stopped short of escalating NHS Grampian to the highest level of government intervention.

    It will remain at a “strengthened” stage four - where it was moved to in May last year after concerns over financial sustainability alongside leadership and governance were identified.

    Stage four means there are significant risks to the delivery of services and the government will provide external senior level support.

    Constance said she would review the situation in six weeks with the option to escalate to stage five still an option.

  8. Health secretary's 'profound sense of concern' over NHS Grampianpublished at 15:08 GMT 17 November

    Health Secretary Angela Constance says she has a "profound sense of concern" over NHS Grampian.

    Her parliamentary statement this afternoon follows a highly-critical Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) report last week.

    "The findings will be distressing for everyone across the north east," she said.

    "Behind these findings are people who placed their trust in the health service and who had every right to expect safe, high-quality care.

    "They deserved better."

  9. Why is NHS Grampian in the spotlight?published at 15:06 GMT 17 November

    Ken Banks
    BBC Scotland North East and Northern Isles reporter

    A busy hospital corridor, a trolley bed is in the foreground, staff with green scrubs are in the distance.Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Healthcare Improvement Scotland raised serious concerns

    A watchdog issued a damning report last week into failures by senior leadership at NHS Grampian.

    Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) found "major deficiencies" across the region - and revealed a failure to learn from mistakes had caused "repeated and avoidable harm" to patients.

    It also said it had lost confidence in management to deliver reliable and consistent information, after Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin continued to operate on children despite an order to halt all paediatric surgery.

    NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight accepted the findings and apologised to patients. First Minister John Swinney called for "dramatic action" to be taken.

  10. Welcomepublished at 14:29 GMT 17 November

    Good afternoon and welcome to our live coverage of First Minister's Questions on Tuesday 17 November.

    John Swinney will take questions from backbench MSPs for about half an hour from 14.30.

    You can follow events in the chamber by clicking on the Watch live icon at the top of this page